Data from 2014.
Posted on 02/24/2022 8:38:14 AM PST by blam
The fog of war is now descending on Ukraine. Things are now likely to move *very* fast, but at time of writing: the leaders of the two breakaway Russian republics had sent official requests to Moscow for military aid against “Ukrainian aggression”; the city of Kiev had declared a state of emergency; the country was again experiencing major cyberattacks; the Russian military had closed all civilian Ukrainian airspace along the country’s eastern border –until 18 May– warning it “may experience a high incidence of aircraft collision with missiles”; European airlines are being told Ukraine as a whole is now a “do not fly”; airports in Kharkiv, Dnipro, and Zaporizhzhya have had their runways blocked with tractors to prevent Russian paratroopers landing there easily; and President Zelenskiy gave a speech that had the feel of being one for the history books. Allow me to quote some of it below from live simultaneous translation on Twitter:
“Today I initiated a phone conversation with the president of the Russian Federation. The result was silence. Although it’s the Donbas where there should be silence…We are divided by a shared border of more than 2,000km. Almost 200,000 of your troops and thousands of military vehicles are standing alongside it. Your leadership has ordered them to move forward, onto another country’s territory. This step could be the start of a big war on the European continent. The whole world is talking about what could happen any day now… Any provocation. Any flare-up – one that could burn everything.”
“They’re telling you that this flame will liberate the people of Ukraine, but the Ukrainian people are free. They remember their past and are building their future… Ukraine on your TV news and the real Ukraine are two totally different countries. Ours is real. They told you I’m ordering an attack on Donbas, to open fire and bomb indiscriminately… to shoot at whom? to bomb whom?”
“I’m speaking Russian, but nobody in Russia understand what these places, streets, and events are. This is our land and our history. What are you fighting for? And with whom? Lots of you have relatives in Ukraine, you studied in Ukrainian universities, you have Ukrainian friends. You know our character, our principles, what matters to us. Listen to yourselves, to the voice of reason.”
“The people of Ukraine want peace. The government of Ukraine wants peace. It’s doing everything it can. We’re not alone. That’s true, lots of countries support Ukraine. Because this isn’t about peace at any price. It’s about peace, principles, justice, international law, the right to determine your own future. This is about society’s right to be safe and people’s rights to live without threats. This is all important for us and for the world. I know for sure that this is important for you too.”
“We know for sure that we don’t need war – neither cold, nor hot, nor hybrid. But if troops attack us and someone tries to take away our country, our freedom, our lives, the lives of our children, then we will defend ourselves. We will defend ourselves. When you attack, you will see our faces, not our backs. War is a great misfortune and it comes at a great price. People lose their money, reputation, freedom, living standards, and most importantly – they lose their loved ones and themselves. Nothing’s ever enough in a war, but there’s more than enough pain, dirt, and death. Tens of thousands of deaths.”
“They’re telling you that Ukraine could be a threat for Russia. That never happened in the past, it’s not, and won’t in the future. You demand security guarantees from NATO. We demand guarantees of our security. The security of Ukraine. From you, Russia, and the other guarantors of the Budapest memorandum. We aren’t in any defensive alliances. Ukraine’s security is tied to our neighbours’ security. Today we need to talk about the security of the whole of Europe. But our main goal is peace in Ukraine and the security of our citizens, Ukrainians. We will tell everyone, including you, in different formats, in any venue.”
“War will take guarantees away from everyone. Nobody will have security guarantees anymore. Who will suffer most of all? People. Who doesn’t want that to happen more than anyone? People. Who can stop that? People. These people are among you. I’m sure. Activists, journalists, musicians, actors, athletes, scientists, doctors, bloggers, stand-up comedians, TikTokers, and many others. Ordinary people, simple people, men, women, the old, the young, fathers, and most of all – mothers. Just like the people in Ukraine. Just like the government in Ukraine. However they try to convince you otherwise.”
“I know that Russian TV won’t show my speech. But citizens of Russia need to see it. They need to see the truth. The truth is you need to stop before it’s too late. And if the leadership of Russia doesn’t want, for the sake of peace, to sit at the table with us, maybe it’ll sit at the table with you. Do the Russians want war? I’d love to answer that question. But the answer only depends on you – citizens of Russia.”
I hope the hair on the back of you necks is standing up, as Zelenskiy had been a consistent voice trying to downplay the risks of Russian invasion. Meanwhile, Russian state TV are showing a map of Ukraine that only names a small central region of the country as “Ukraine”, with the rest of its territory titled “Gifts from the (Russian) czars; gifts from Lenin; gift from Stalin; gift from Khruschev.” The messaging is clear. And, no, the Russian people who see that will not also get to hear Zelenskiy’s call for them to rise up in protest – but it will be taken as a further attack by a paranoid Moscow after what happened in both Belarus and Kazakhstan.
In short, just as we flagged a month ago, it appears we are headed for a serious war in Ukraine starting as soon as today. Given the failure of Russia to achieve any of its political goals vis-à-vis Ukraine, except a lack of NATO membership that was already unlikely to ever change, this only raises the strategic imperative to use more military force. Indeed, if war starts then we won’t have seen a Russian operation on such a scale since the Second Chechen War of 1999-2000. Here are some images of that to sober you.
We have already shown what this is likely to mean for markets: further downside for equities; and for bond yields – and another huge problem central banks don’t understand and cannot control; huge increases in key commodity prices; higher inflation (only NOW about Ukraine!); lower economic growth; and in FX, a stronger US dollar and JPY, a far weaker ruble, and while CNY will remain pegged to the US for now, one wonders how other EM FX will fare as prices soar. But this is just the start.
Will we see more biting sanctions as a result of these actions? The ones we have already seen were either deliberately designed to scare, not hurt, or were drawn up by people who don’t understand Russia at all. If we stick with milquetoast measures, Russia is unshaken; if we impose harsh sanctions, markets are shaken. Which is it to be? Consider this current Russian military move has been slow and deliberate. That means it has planned out all possible Western responses and likely costs. Are they factoring in that the West won’t sanction them, or that they can thrive even if they do?
If Europe’s borders are now to be redrawn by force, so will geopolitics be. Poland and Lithuania now back Ukraine for EU membership. Of course, the West of the EU will reject that for many reasons – but intra-EU tensions may rise at this lack of solidarity at a time of crisis. Finland’s PM has just flagged it may join NATO. Again, this leaves Russia in a far worse national security position – unless it can achieve a major victory in Ukraine that won’t come via posturing or a de minimis attack. China’s looming strategic decision is also clear, as noted yesterday. Despite censoring all of Putin’s attacks on Lenin’s errors this week (which are taboo: Mao broke from the USSR after Khrushchev broke from Stalin over Marxist ideology, and Vietnam censored the news too), Beijing is so far blaming this all on the US for supporting Ukraine, which has parallels that should be clear.
If Europe’s borders are now to be redrawn by force, so will geoeconomics be. Aside from sanctions, long just-in-time global supply chains tried to shrug off the US-China trade war; then Covid; now they have to deal with war. How long until governments enforce supply-chain ‘resilience’ on firms that opt to do the complete opposite of taking out economic insurance and so leave the entire national economy more vulnerable while they make higher profits? e.g., on-shoring or shortening supply chains; having multiple import and export markets; and/or limiting dealing with states/entities that are well known ‘risk points’. In peacetime, the answer might be “they won’t, because markets”; in wartime, is that still true? We shall see, but the historical track record is pretty clear – national security wins by knock-out. And what of governments that have actively supported such non-resilient business strategies “because mercantilism”? How long until allies lean on them “because national security”? Think of what just happened to Nord Stream 2, and what we argued about Germany’s existential choices in ‘“Ich Bin Ein Berliner”(?)’.
Expect a risk-off day in markets. Expect major volatility. Expect the fog of war: known and unknown unknowns, fake news, false flags, and even censorship can all be expected; sadly, so can “pain, dirt, and death”. And don’t expect this to be resolved by the end of the day, or the end of the week, or the end of the month.
Huh? IIRC Brandon reminded us HE has nukes and F-15s. Oh, for white supremacist destruction here at home.
This ties in with an interesting email I got yesterday:
Below is a letter from a genealogist/geneticist discussing Russia and the Ukraine:
All eyes are on Eastern Europe...
What’s going on over there?
Is history repeating itself?
What are they fighting about?
Well, I promised a geneticist’s perspective...
And genetically speaking, there isn’t a ton to talk about...
Ethnically speaking, “Russians” and “Ukrainians” are two distinct groups.
Genetically speaking, those two ethnic groups are VERY similar.
This is due to the extensive shared history the two civilizations have.
In fact, the very first “Russian” nation and very first “Ukrainian” nation were the same!
If you look at the history of Russia and Ukraine, the first distinct nation in the history of both was the Kievan Rus’. During the 10th and 11th centuries (the Middle Ages), this was the largest and most powerful state in Europe.
For almost 300 years, the capital city of both “Ukraine” and “Russia” was Kyiv. It’s known in history as “the Golden Age of Kyiv.”
The Kievan Rus’ fell victim to Mongolian conquests in the 13th century. For several centuries after the fall, the region of Ukraine was largely under the control of its neighbors, such as Lithuania and Poland.
Meanwhile, a new Russian nation was already forming in Moscow by the 14th century. First known as the Grand Duchy of Moscow, it laid the foundation for the Tsardom of Russia that lasted until the 20th century and saw a massive expansion of borders.
In the 17th century, the region of Ukraine was included in that expansion of borders. This was the first time Ukrainians were subjected to specifically-Russian rule.
When the Tsardom fell to revolution in 1917, an independent Ukraine emerged that same year... Well, a couple independent Ukraines, really. Ukraine was relatively prosperous for a few years while Russia was engulfed in civil war.
However, regional disputes and revolution drowned this newly independent Ukraine in civil war by 1919. The newly formed Soviet Union in Russia took advantage of the conflict to retake most of Ukraine by the 1920s.Whatever Ukraine’s relationship with Russia was like in the past, it was not particularly smooth under Soviet leadership...
A massive famine occurred in the 1930s that’s known as the Holomodor. The term “Holomodor” refers to the man-made causes of the famine, including a rejection of foreign aid, confiscation of food, and restriction of movement enforced by Soviet authorities. It was an unprecedented peacetime catastrophe that cost millions of lives, most of which were ethnic Ukrainians. Today’s Ukraine and several other nations, including the United States, consider it a genocide against Ukrainian people.
In 1986, Ukraine suffered another unprecedented peacetime catastrophe: the Chernobyl nuclear reactor explosion. While certainly not intentional, this was another costly disaster at the hands of Soviet authorities.
By 1990, Ukrainian people were protesting in the streets. Massive groups would stand together holding hands, forming human chains as a show of unity.
Ukraine achieved independence once again in 1991, alongside several other nations seceding from the Soviet Union. Today’s Russian Federation formed not long after.
With this much history intertwined, it’s not too surprising that ethnic Ukrainians and ethnic Russians are very genetically similar to each other.
Even today, the two nations are significantly intertwined, as over 3 million ethnic Ukrainians live in Russia and almost 7 million ethnic Russians live in Ukraine.
So what’s all the fighting about??
Well, unfortunately, some of the worst fights happen within the family...
I’m not sure if a “happy ending” is possible with this one, but I’m holding onto hope that peace prevails.
That’s all for today. Thanks for reading.
Sincerely,
Alexei Fedorov,
CRI Genetics
Everything he said is irrefutably true. Putin is not “preserving the Union,” as some horse’s ass on FR is claiming. He’s trying to reconquer a conquered territory that Russia lost in 1991.
China should use this opportunity to take Taiwan
In the end the Russian people and the Russian nation will suffer the most. Putin has made a catastrophic misjudgment which will negate the progress Russia, despite spotty political leadership, has made over the last thirty years. They were beginning to evolve from the catastrophic , murderous debilitation of nearly ninety years of vile communist rule.
It’ll be over in a week.
I’d prefer China not take Taiwan, but can’t blame them if they do.
The thing about war is that the other side gets to fight back.
Data from 2014.
Always had the impression of Ukraine as being evenly divided between the don’t take crap and another group of whatever. So don’t know if the guys who are fighting will cause a slaughter of the whatevers which might spark them to resist too.
Thanks.
Close to 50% of my dna/ancestors came from early European
Hunter-Gathers, 45,000 years ago.
Explains why there were very few farmers and ranchers in my ancestor pool.
EXCELLENT material.
Trust nothing. Going to be a lot of Deep Fakes, and misleading videos.
Thanks.
Unfortunately, we often only listen to real historians after a war based on B$ is waged and a lot of innocent people are slaughtered.
Then it is too late.
““The people of Ukraine want peace. The government of Ukraine wants peace. It’s doing everything it can.”
Then they shouldn’t have shelled, surrounded and attacked the separatist areas for 8 years. They should have allowed the autonomy elections specified in Minsk 1 and 2. They shouldn’t have dammed the water supply canal to Crimea. They shouldn’t have allowed nazi symbology and militias into their military and government. They shouldn’t have colluded with Biden and the democrats for bribery and impeaching Trump.
Play stupid games, win stupid prizes. Screw em.
The Russian maps are insane. Russia annexed land from the Polish-Lithuanian Empire, and then years later, the Soviet Union created a system of subservient, autocratic regional governments and included that land with the older lands which the Kiev, Warsaw, Gdansk and Vilnius liberated from the Golden Horde. And now Russia wants them to be thankful they are NOT Poland?
I intend to add my predictions of the outcome of this event sometime in the future.
Looking at the latest news, I’d say this was “resolved” about 12 hours ago.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.