No I mean failed in that he’s not funny. His primary bit before he found this gig was complaining about comedians stealing other comedians’ material. But he never managed to accuse anybody of stealing his material. Which says all you need to know.
Actually, he did accuse Carlos Mencia of stealing his jokes and many other comedian’s jokes.
There is a YouTube video out there of Rogan confronting Mencia on stage about his plagiarizing