Posted on 02/26/2021 1:26:07 PM PST by nickcarraway
The California State Supreme Court has issued its ruling on Senate Bill 1391, which was challenged in the case of Adrian “A.J.” Gonzalez, the accused killer of 8-year-old Madyson “Maddy” Middleton.
In a written opinion issued on Thursday, the court stated that SB 1391 was constitutional. The law, which went into effect in 2019, prevents anyone under the age of 16 years old being tried as an adult.
The Middleton Family released a statement after the supreme court ruling.
"The decision by the California Supreme Court that SB 1391 is constitutional is absolutely disappointing to our family. We have thought long and hard about what we desire from the justice system in regards to this case. No punishment can ever undo what was done or bring our beloved Maddy back to us. However, at the very least, it is our hope that this act does not happen again. We believe that the heinous nature of the crime, level of sophistication and manipulation, planning and cover-up indicates all of the characteristics of a psychopathic killer, who needs to be kept away from our children and society. It is our firm belief that the California Juvenile Justice System, as it exists today, is not capable of adequately dealing with this type of individual. For us, the worst has already happened. We will now see where this path leads," said Dan Middleton, Madyson’s grandfather.
A.J., who is now 21 but was 15-years-old at the time of the crime, allegedly raped and murdered Maddy, could now go free when he turns 25.
In 2019 SB 1391 was ruled unconstitutional by a Santa Cruz County Superior Court judge before it was taken to the state supreme court.
In 2020, lawyers argued before the state supreme court on the constitutionality of the law. Some argue it's unconstitutional because it overrides the will of the voters who passed Proposition 57 allowing judges not prosecutors to decide whether minors, including 14 and 15 year olds, should be tried as adults.
“We believe that the California juvenile system, as it stands today, cannot deal with a person such as Adrian Gonzalez we feel that he has to remain in the adult system in order to take care of him. He is not an innocent child that should be coming out when he's 25 years old,” said Dan Middleton, Maddy’s grandfather, in an interview with KSBW 8 in November 2020.
But supporters of SB 1391 argue that prosecutors are politicizing the law and they say juvenile offenders no matter how egregious the crime they allegedly commit should remain in juvenile court where they qualify for release at age 25.
Gonzalez remains behind bars in the Santa Cruz County jail.
Read the Supreme Court of California ruling, here.
He's already 21, so does this mean he goes free now?
I will say it would be an obstacle for the defense attorney to have an adult male sitting at the defense table, when he was 15 when he committed the crime.
It was a tragedy when we have children killing children.
Santa Cruz Ping
Judges are just scumbag lawyers who got promoted for being ‘really good scumbags’.
I have a healthy fear of them,(pitbulls too), but no respect.
Contempt would be a better word...
WIKI - The California Supremes and who appointed them
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_justices_of_the_Supreme_Court_of_California
Carol Corrigan January 4, 2006 Present Governor Schwarzenegger
Tani Cantil-Sakauye* January 3, 2011 Present Governor Schwarzenegger
Goodwin Liu September 1, 2011 Present Governor J. Brown
Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar January 5, 2015 Present Governor J. Brown
Leondra R. Kruger January 5, 2015 Present Governor J. Brown
Joshua P. Groban January 3, 2019 Present Governor J. Brown
Martin Jenkins December 4, 2020 Present Governor Newsom
WIKI - The California Supremes and who appointed them
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_justices_of_the_Supreme_Court_of_California
Carol Corrigan January 4, 2006 Present Governor Schwarzenegger
Tani Cantil-Sakauye* January 3, 2011 Present Governor Schwarzenegger
Goodwin Liu September 1, 2011 Present Governor J. Brown
Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar January 5, 2015 Present Governor J. Brown
Leondra R. Kruger January 5, 2015 Present Governor J. Brown
Joshua P. Groban January 3, 2019 Present Governor J. Brown
Martin Jenkins December 4, 2020 Present Governor Newsom
He knew right from wrong when he did it.
He should have paid. But this is the state we are in now.
The Left wants to give the vote to 12 year old kids, presumably to allow them to enter into contracts, have consensual sexual relations, and everything else they can get.
But they will still maintain that a 12 year old, legally allowed to vote and have consensual sex, is incapable of knowing right from wrong.
This is why cognitive dissonance in them creates such hateful and twisted people on the Left.
Sick.
No. It is murder, has always been murder, when ANY PERSON deliberately assaults and rapes and kills ANY victim.
He - and his self-called “juvenile defenders” and promoters - are gaming the system so he will be able to go out and rape against.
Who said it was not murder? No one said that.
If I ever get anywhere near this POS he’s dying.
“Scumbag” is way too kind. People who would want to set someone like this free are inhuman monsters.
Many years ago, in what now seems like a previous life, I worked as a teacher in a juvenile prison. I worked with two murders. Both were, I think 13 when they killed. The first, along with his twin killed his step-father and left their step-mother for dead, not for a lack of trying to kill her. (I know, two step parents—complicated). The other helped his friend kill his friend’s mother—with an axe.
According to the law at the time, both were released on their 18th birthdays, with of course their records expunged. Technically, they weren’t convicted of murder in juvenile court, but rather were declared delinquent. Thus the first murderer (and his brother) shared the insurance settlement with their step-mother. I’ve been told that such a thing can’t happen, but I saw the check that was deposited into the killer’s canteen account.
Any family worth their salt would have put this scum into the ground a long time ago...
Do you know if they reoffended, etc?
 | CЯUZIO |
| Send FReepmail if you want on/off the SANTA CЯUZ COUNTY CA ping list | |
 | |
| This is why we can't have nice things | |
| The List of Ping Lists | |
Do you know if they reoffended, etc?
.............letting this creep off with ten years will guarantee more Maddie’s are similarly butchered. There must be a degree of accountability for any official paroling one of these bastards. At a rock bottom minimum, they should be fired from their job IF they let people like this out and they kill again.
I think where The Left is confused is not understanding that the most egregious criminals, like this one, should NEVER get out. But, as opposed to NOTHING, something bad should happen to parole board members who let one out that kills again.
I am watching a YT video about serial killers [Ed Kemper, Gerald Schaeffer, Ottis Toole] and they made a real point about the fantasies started for these men while they were still in elementary school. Very young, maybe 9 or 10 the motivation was already there. People who are this sick are not curable.
Maybe they can give him last rites and a cigarette...
Teenagers ‘think’ of all sorts of foolish and dangerous ideas these days but rarely think of the consequences if they carry these out. Rather they want to see how the public reacts.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.