Anti-Americanism: The New Anti-Semitism

And why is that? Why does the left (not liberals, the left hate America and Israel?

In "Why the Jews; The Reason for Antisemitism," a book I co-authored with Rabbi Joseph Telushkin in 1983 (the latest edition was published in 2016), we compared hatred of America with hatred of Jews.

This is what we wrote. It precisely explains what is happening in America today.

"Perhaps the best way to understand the admiration and resentment elicited by the quality of Jewish life is to compare the reactions of the world to America's quality of life. No other country has so many people seeking to move there. At the same time, no country, with the exception of Israel, is the target of so many hateful and false attacks.

"The United States, because of its success and its ideals, challenges many people throughout the world. How did America, a nation composed largely of those rejected by other societies ('The wretched refuse of your teeming shore' declare the words at the base of the Statue of Liberty), become the most affluent, freest, most powerful, and most influential society in the world? Americans generally attribute this success to the values of America's founding generations (such as individual liberty, religious tolerance, Judeo-Christian morality, and secular government), to a work ethic, and to the subsequent waves of immigrants who embraced these values. Enemies of America attribute it to the country's natural resources, just as many people attribute Jewish success to their natural resource, alleged greater innate intelligence. Others claim that through capitalist exploitation, America cheated poorer countries, paralleling charges that Jewish success has been attained through economic 'bloodsucking.' Still others develop an imperialist version of America's past and present, similar to the anti-Jewish charge of a world Jewish conspiracy.

"But the United States is hardly the only society with great natural resources, and it has been the least imperialistic of the world's powers. America's values, not unfair resource distribution or world exploitation, have made the United States better, just as Judaism and its values, not genetic advantage or economic conspiracies, account for the quality of life led by Jews. The two people's quality of life has provoked similar reactions -- many admire them, and many resent them."

Just like the Jews, America is hated because it is successful. For over a century, it has been the most successful country in the world -- in virtually every way. If having had slavery was a real issue in the left's anti-Americanism, the left would hate the Arab world and Latin American countries such as Brazil more than it hates the United States. While The New York Times and other left-wing institutions are preoccupied with slavery in America, they ignore -- out of ideological nonconcern or out of sheer ignorance -- the vastly larger number of Africans enslaved by Muslim and South American nations.

Of the more than 12 million African slaves shipped to the Western Hemisphere, only about 3% -- between 306,000 and 380,000 -- were sent to the United States. The other 97% were sent to the Caribbean and Brazil. And the slaves in the U.S. South lived longer and made larger families than the slaves of Latin America. Yet, the U.S. is singled out for hatred. Why? Because the left doesn't resent Brazil. Brazil is not an object of envy.

Likewise, there is no left-wing hatred of the Arab world, which enslaved far more blacks than the North and South Americas combined did. The internationally recognized expert on African history, Senegalese anthropologist Tidiane N'Diaye, wrote: "Most people still have the so-called Transatlantic (slave) trade by Europeans into the New World in mind. But in reality the Arab-Muslim slavery was much greater. ... The Arab Muslims were the most murderous of all those involved in the slave trade." Part of that murderous treatment of African slaves involved castrating the males so they could not reproduce. And the women and girls were traded as sex slaves.

Where is the leftist anger at the Arab and Muslim world? There is, of course, none. On the contrary, the left protects the Muslim and Arab world against moral criticism.

The left hates America for its success and influence on the world, just as anti-Semites hated Jews for their success and influence on the world.

The left doesn't hate America because it is bad. It hates America because it is good. If the left hated evil, it would love America and hate its enemies.

“Why does the left (not liberals, the left hate America and Israel?”

I don’t distinguish between the two. They are all democrats with the “liberals” providing the underlying philosophical and political underpinnings (the ‘brains” of the movement as it were) for the destruction of America. The Alan Dershowitzs’ of the world will talk good smack then turn around and vote for Hillary Clinton. All against the wall.

There is a lot of truth to what Prager says but what he says is incomplete and disingenuous.

The history of the Jews is ancient and as well “documented” as the history of any other identifiable group of people. What the Jews face and have always faced is the dilemma of fitting in wherever they are, and that dilemma is solved in many (understandable) ways, both good and bad.

Prager’s comparison with America is apt but superficial.

Just on a totally subjective note, it may well be that America’s role in the divine plan is to protect the Jewish nation. We are certainly doing so now, ironically despite the hatred many American Jews have for America (in their bizarre devotion to leftist perspectives.)

Again subjective, the American nation and the Jewish nation are both unique in history, but the resemblance is far more complicated (or non-existent) than Prager suggests.

“The wretched refuse of your teeming shore’ declare the words at the base of the Statue of Liberty)...”

How can a serious person quote that to back up an erroneous statement? It was added to the Statue twenty years after it was placed by a Socialist one-worlder. The people who settled America were not royalty, but they were the bold ones in their populations.

The core of American society was developed over a period of about 175 years prior to the American Revolution by a native population stemming from British settlers.

Dennis Prager is one of my favorites. There is something about his writing. Perhaps it is because I hear his soothing voice when I read his words, or maybe it is because he makes such cogent an logical arguments. He is a rare treasure.

You nailed it. Success generates envy that turns into hatred. The most unforgivable crimes a country can commit are freedom and prosperity. The big lie is that wealth can only be stolen and can’t be created.

Sorry but I think Dennis Prager missed it. Yes, part of it is the envy thing but it goes much deeper than that. In the mid 50’s, Groucho Marx stated that the best way to get ahead in television was to break as many of the 10 Commandments during your show as possible. I think you can see from that statement that we are getting a little closer to the real issue. Anything that seems to represent the God of the Bible - be it the Jews, Israel, America, our Constitution, churches, Christians, crosses, moral absolutes, even rational thought, etc. are all fair targets for ridicule and hatred in the eyes of the left. Psalm 2 and Romans 1 tend to show the contempt the world has for the things of God. And let’s not forget, we are all guilty. “There is none righteous. No, not one…” Some have just made peace and are reconciled to their Creator. As we draw closer to the close of the age, God’s Word warns that the worst is yet to come. The wheels are about to come totally off.

I’ve been thinking about this the past few days.

The parallel is valid, maybe not in the historical sense you describe. But in the context of the nazi’s and how the “judas” were persecuted by unelected mobs, white people are being persecuted in a similar manner.

What we’re seeing is the resurrection of a prolonged night of the long knives.

Next I believe will be polling place intimation. The same way Hitler came to power is happening here.

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.