Yes. He was a good college QB.
He was not so good playing in the bigs.
And why the insult? How was that nescessary? You sound like a mean person. Does calling someone a name make you feel better? Do you wait all day, being a servant to others, to come home to the Internet to be a tough guy? It sounds weak.
How how sensitive you are after calling a Heisman Trophy Winner “middling”. How is “armchair” any worse?