Posted on 01/07/2019 5:14:25 PM PST by be-baw
President Trump has suggested that he might resort to using "emergency" powers to build his border wall if he is not able to reach agreement on funding with congressional Democrats.
"We are looking at it very strongly," Trump told reporters on Sunday. "We're looking at a national emergency, because we have a national emergency."
The president does have broad powers to act in a crisis situation, but those powers are not unlimited. And critics say Trump should be careful about invoking them in this instance.
Here are five facts about Trump's emergency powers and the border wall.
1. What are a president's emergency powers?
There are dozens of laws that give the president special powers to act in an emergency. For example, in an emergency, the president is allowed to divert money to military construction projects, which could conceivably include the border wall.
"Declaring the emergency is pretty easy," said Elizabeth Goitein, co-director of the Liberty and National Security Program at the Brennan Center for Justice. "There aren't a lot of legal limits on his ability to do that, frankly, even if there isn't a real emergency happening."
2. What say does Congress have?
In the mid-1970s, Congress passed a law designed to provide some check on the president's power while also preserving flexibility to act in an emergency. The National Emergencies Act requires the president to notify Congress when an emergency is declared and to list the powers that are being invoked. The law requires the administration to provide regular updates to Congress, and allows lawmakers to terminate an emergency if both House and Senate vote to do so.
3. Would congressional critics have recourse if Trump invoked emergency powers?
Congress could reject the president's emergency declaration with a vote in both the House and Senate. But the Republican-controlled Senate seems unlikely to take that step. Instead, critics would very likely pursue a legal challenge.
"I think the president would be wide open to a court challenge saying, 'Where's the emergency?' " Rep. Adam Smith, D-Wash., chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, told ABC.
Goitein also cautioned that a resort to emergency powers in the current situation — in the midst of a standoff with lawmakers that has produced a partial government shutdown — could be considered an abuse of the president's power.
"Emergency powers are intended to be used for emergencies, not to settle political disputes or to shortcut the political process," Goitein said.
4. What is the emergency?
The president has described the situation on the U.S.-Mexico border as both a humanitarian and national security crisis.
"We have criminals coming in," Trump said Sunday. "We have human traffickers coming in. We have drugs pouring in. We have things happening that you don't want to even know about."
The administration has also raised the specter of terrorists crossing the border, although many of these claims are overblown.
What has happened on the border in recent months is a surge of Central American families seeking asylum. U.S. law and and court orders make it difficult to quickly deport these families or detain them for an extended period while their asylum claims are adjudicated.
5. Would a wall help?
Trump has insisted since the 2016 campaign that a physical barrier along the U.S. border with Mexico is the solution to what he sees as a crisis.
"Walls work," the president wrote in a letter to lawmakers last week. "That's why rich, powerful, and successful people build them around their homes. All Americans deserve the same protection."
Critics say the president's faith in a wall is misplaced.
"It's a spectacularly bad idea, a complete waste of money," Smith told NPR. "The only emergency we have on the border right now is people seeking asylum. And people seeking asylum are not trying to sneak in. They're turning themselves in and asking for a hearing."
NPR's Tamara Keith contributed to this report.
What did any of this matter with Obama’s undeclared wars and other foreign sorties?
“What did any of this matter with Obama’s undeclared wars and other foreign sorties?”
I’m drawing a blank...not sure what undeclared wars and sorties to which you refer.
“The only emergency we have on the border right now is people seeking asylum. And people seeking asylum are not trying to sneak in. “
right so why are many not going to port of entry but being found crossing in plenty of other spots? also some are trying to evade border patrol before apprehension.
Throughout our history the President has declared a national emergency to build x.
A wall, dam, airport, locks, levies etc.
Imho, the President (nice to capitalize that again), should declare a national emergency and build an island twelve miles off the coast of Shanghai.
5.56mm
There! Fixed it.
Mr. Horsley is seemingly trying to nullify the votes of the patriots who elected PDJT.
Isn't the reciprocal argument to that a claim that congress isn't properly exercising it's power to prevent a foreign invasion of the US?
Based on recent polls the 62 million number is probably quite low.
More than 70,000 died of drug overdoses last year, not an emergency if non of them were your family member.
Human trafficing, homocides of Americans, MS 13 gangs, no problem if all you want is political power and cheap labor.
No problem for rich Dems who have walls and private and public protective details.
‘Isn’t the reciprocal argument to that a claim that congress isn’t properly exercising it’s power to prevent a foreign invasion of the US?”
Congress’ failure to address the problems in the immigration laws, along with Obama’s getting away with his unlawful executive orders, are really the root of the entire problem.
Congress’ failure to do their jobs has really become a national embarrassment, and I honestly don’t see it changing. The useless bastards keep getting re-elected.
Hanford, Oak Ridge, Los Alamos
I, for one, really hope our President doesn’t take this route.
Simply dig and no compromise, keep the shutdown going and let the chips fall where the will.
I can't imagine the SC taking that case. The remedy is in Congress's hands -- impeachment and removal from office. The House would certainly impeach him. I don't see the Senate removing him from office over this but who knows? There are lots of RINOs.
Canals...etc.
5.56mm
Give a bit more time and advances in high tech there can be in the future electronic force field barriers.
Use Soetoro’s technique of using fixed wing drones with Hellfire missiles.
Good point.
Syria
Yeah, that’s definitely an example. One I didn’t think of when I was pondering the question.
The drug overdose of a really good point.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.