Posted on 09/25/2018 10:24:59 AM PDT by richardb72
Judicial confirmations have become a blood sport. Wasnt it just weeks ago at John McCains funeral that Democrats were calling for more civility in politics? We never used to fight so much over Supreme Court nominations.
Eighty-seven justices were nominated between 1789 and 1950, and the time from nomination to Senate vote averaged just over eleven days. But this changed dramatically over the next half century. From 1951 through 1975, the average confirmation process increased to more than 50 days. Between 1976 and the present, it has averaged at least 75 days (the average rises to 90 days if we count Merrick Garland, whose nomination lapsed after a new Congress was seated in 2017, though it could be argued that his nomination was rejected immediately).
Democrats have opposed Brett Kavanaugh both times that he has been considered for a judgeship. When he was nominated to the D.C. Circuit Court in 2003, his confirmation battle lasted 1,036 days. There were no allegations of sexual misconduct that caused that delay.
Kavanaughs circuit-court confirmation battle was the seventh-longest of the 366 that occurred from the beginning of Carters administration through to the end of Obamas. Bill Clintons circuit-court confirmation averaged 231 days, George W. Bushs 362, and Obamas 278.
Democrats are hoping to delay Kavanaughs Supreme Court confirmation until after the November election. If Democrats win control of the Senate, they would then vote down the nomination. Democrats may have had information of Kavanaughs supposed sexual behavior when he was 17 since July; by raising it now, after the hearings and just days before the scheduled Judiciary Committee vote, they have timed it to delay the process.
Kavanaughs résumé is stellar. He attended Yale Law School and clerked for the Supreme Court. He has taught at Harvard, Yale, and Georgetown law schools. The Supreme Court has frequently adopted his reasoning on a variety of issues.
Despite Democratic claims, he is not a radical who will overturn decisions such as Roe v. Wade. Kavanaugh was a consistent follower of precedent when he was on the D.C. Circuit Court. While the Supreme Court can overrule its own precedent, Kavanaugh has co-authored a hefty 942-page book on precedent, titled Law of Judicial Precedent. The book seeks to formally describe rules for when courts should follow precedent, and it makes clear that jettisoning precedent is not something that Kavanaugh takes lightly.
But the opposition has always been so fierce precisely because Kavanaugh is so qualified. Democrats dont just fear his judicial philosophy they also fear him because he is smart....
Bill Clintons circuit-court confirmation averaged 231 days, George W. Bushs 362, and Obamas 278.
-
Hey. Why isnt that linear? I think we know.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.