Posted on 07/14/2018 1:16:41 PM PDT by Mrs. Don-o
Family planning advocates are working hard to position contraceptives as the key to achieving the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). As an event on Tuesday demonstrated, however, their arguments collapse under closer scrutiny.
The Wilson Center event was the third in a series focusing on the benefits of family planning for peace and security, societal resilience, and global development. Similar to previous events, the panelists stressed the importance of access to family planning and estimated the cost savings of reductions in fertility, but glossed over how to push more contraceptives in a world approaching market saturation.
In a departure from the event’s theme, keynote speaker Peter McPherson, former head of USAID, provided a brief history of the agency’s family planning work, focusing on his tenure during the Reagan administration. He recounted a telephone call with Mother Teresa, in which she urged him to “protect the unborn.” In contrast, he recalled how then-Planned Parenthood president Faye Wattleton, upset by the exclusion of abortion from family planning programs, paid for large advertisements on D.C. buses saying, “Administrator McPherson Kills Women.” He said Wattleton’s campaign, “absolutely cemented” his position in the White House because “Reagan thought [the signs] were great.”
Jay Gribble, deputy director of the Health Policy Plus Project, argued that investment in family planning would help to meet several of the SDGs, and discussed a USAID-sponsored tool to help advocates make the case for family planning based on multiple goals. He estimated that Malawi, for instance, could achieve between 60% and 68% contraceptive prevalence by 2020. Yet he did not explain how this increase in use can be achieved, especially given that only 2% of Malawian women with “unmet need” claim a lack of access to family planning,
Cornell professor Parfait Eloundou-Enyegue, noted that some have questioned whether there is a demand for family planning. He asserted that there is a demand, particularly among youth, if you broaden the definition to encompass “life planning” apart from just planning births. However, when a young man in the audience later asked what specific programming exists for young people to plan their lives apart from not getting pregnant Eloundou-Enyegue admitted, “precious little.”
Eloundou-Enyegue noted the broad agreement of the audience in favor of family planning, referring to his presentation as “preaching to the choir.” Even so, several attendees commented on what they perceived as a pervasive “dump on Africa” tone to the event.
Marlene Lee of the Population Reference Bureau spoke about the “demographic dividend” and stressed the fact that it is not automatic and depends on a variety of factors, including corruption, good governance, and the education of the emerging workforce.
Later in the discussion, Gribble pointed out that “the demographic dividend got picked up by family planning advocates because it was a way to get people outside of the health sector to say, ‘Oh, this stuff isn’t so bad after all, its going to help us get wealthier.’” He noted, however, that the concept has been greatly oversimplified at the expense of its economic and governance aspects.
Gribble quipped, “when it’s a group of family planning people, it doesn’t matter what the question is, family planning is always part of the answer.”
Yes but are they answered by contraception?
At some point, soon, like in the next 5 years, the various European welfare states will start collapsing and be unable to provide food for those who will not work. Things will then start getting very interesting.
The problem is, they've convinced themselves that prosperity causes global warming and will doom all life on earth.
“It isn't so much that liberals are ignorant. It's just that they know so many things that aren't so”; Ronald Wilson Reagan.
Funny picture. White person giving a black contraception. Can’t see the white. Must be Margaret Sanger. You know the one who advocated killing black babies.
Only the people whose financial, political or global goals involve contraception, can confidently answer that question.
You forgot increasing th ebudget.
From your point of view, what ar people for?
Not the lights. Heat and entertainment (TV) killed birth rates. When you cold and boredom - sex.
Remedial birth control....
Naw I’m not about Gaia. I am about stupid, mean, rude, classless humans not interacting with me.
Skynet is inevitable.
How many solutions come out the average druggie, grade school drop out, wife beater, drunk or the Wal-Mart shopper from Slidell?
Just what do you have against Slidell?
When I was doing that post Live PD was on the tv and they were at the Wal-Mart in Slidell. No solutions there, in fact a shoplifter was the subject of interest.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.