Replies

Your response didn't address the point that I raised. You describe yourself as an "all-out Zionist" or something like that. This means that you presumably agree with Israel's policy of only admitting Jewish immigrants as future citizens, because a non-Jewish Israel would by definition no longer be Israel.

Yet you think that admitting tens of millions of Mexicans (as long as, according to you, "they're willing to work") to the US is a great idea, ignoring the fact that a United States with a majority Mexican and Central American demographic would no longer be the United States. If you think that the character of the US will not be radically changed by admitting tens of millions more meso-Americans, I suggest that you compare the socioeconomic and educational achievements of typical Anglo-American communities with the squalor of border towns with Mexican majorities. The Meso-American culture and mindset is quite a different beast from that of the US, and no amount of "vetting" will change that.

In other words, you seem to believe that Israel has the right to maintain its ethno-cultural and linguistic identity while the United States (and presumably other western nations) do not. Why not adopt a more logically consistent position where all nations - Israel, the US, European nations, are entitled to maintain their cultural, linguistic, and when applicable, ethnic identities?

Were you ever a debater?

You describe yourself as an "all-out Zionist" or something like that.

Or something like that? Yes. I am a Zionist. Israel has a charter, a constitution, like that of the USA. They are two different countries. I have lived in Mauritania and other countries. They are different and have different standards, constitutions, etc. The US Constitution does not recognize it as, say, a Mormon state.

Yet you think that admitting tens of millions of Mexicans...

What? Didn't say that. Majority what? Character what?

You already live in a country whose "character has been changed..." You elected Barack Hussein Obama.

Border towns? Where are you coming from? I have been all over Mexico. Have you? Can you imagine if SMART immigration policies allowed Mexico's best, brighter, hardest workers to be LEGAL?

What is an "Anglo-American community?" The Hamptons? They elected Barack, too.

Why not adopt a more logically consistent position where all nations...

Because I am not a globalist. I believe in national self-determination barring extreme cases such as Nazi Germany's holocaust, North Korea's starvation, state sponsorship of terror, etc.