Posted on 08/31/2017 8:20:51 AM PDT by EliRoom8
Seems to me it would be a good way to show the Norks they are wasting resources. But I ain’t a big shot War College graduate.
“it’s just an enlightening “
Anything asking such a dumb questions isn’t “enlightening’.
Exactly. I don't know how good our capabilities are in connection with shooting down missiles. However, I do not have any doubt that the Chinese are watching with close attention, and may be supporting these NK launches so that they can gain intelligence on our missile defense program. They would learn where the orders come from, how quickly they are executed, how they are executed, and how well the defenses work, among other things. They might even find information that would help them try to hack our controls. Who knows? In any event, unless the shoot down is actually needed to prevent a nuclear tipped missile from reaching its destination, better to not give China (and Russia) that information.
In other words, it's useless in a real time threat.
Phat Boi can now hit the Pacific Ocean with 100% accuracy.
That missile was not a threat. IF we fired and missed the implications would be that Fat Boy would be very emboldened
Let em burn fuel
Within ten seconds of launch
Oh shut up. Do you really want to start WE III firing at a nothing burger?
All that, plus the fact that within minutes (Seconds?) of launch, the missile’s speed and trajectory are known, and the final resting place can be calculated, by Korea, Japan and the US.
If it’s in the sea, fine , do nothing, except make lots of noises.
If it’s on the land, shoot it down and make lots of smoke from whence it came...................
Actually, when a system is deployed (like Guam) the radar is on and the system is ready to launch. It takes some time to get to this readiness position, but once there you can stay. The time involved in a test is taken up by the test launch vehicle and the test data capture requirements. That is not going to be used if the launch is a real enemy launch. We can shoot them down if they come into the zone of protection. (I don’t know how big that is, and the last NK missile may not have been in the target zone from Guam.)
However the best explanation is the one that implies we may be recovering the pieces and checking them out for technology upgrades. (This sounds like something we would do.) If we shoot at one of the missiles or warheads Etc, there would not be anything left to analyze.
Actually, when a system is deployed (like Guam) the radar is on and the system is ready to launch. It takes some time to get to this readiness position, but once there you can stay. The time involved in a test is taken up by the test launch vehicle and the test data capture requirements. That is not going to be used if the launch is a real enemy launch. We can shoot them down if they come into the zone of protection. (I don’t know how big that is, and the last NK missile may not have been in the target zone from Guam.)
However the best explanation is the one that implies we may be recovering the pieces and checking them out for technology upgrades. (This sounds like something we would do.) If we shoot at one of the missiles or warheads Etc, there would not be anything left to analyze.
Shooting down a Nork missile when it is not necessary to preserve the target gives the Norks telemetric information about the capabilities of the anti-missile and directs their development of countermeasures.
The Iron Dome has a phenomenal record. Now that we have a President willing to build and test a defense system and cooperation no doubt from the little nation the size of NJ, I’m sure you’ll be alive to see the result.
Thank you.
Free target practice.
Been asking that for months.
***crickets***
“Why Didn’t the US Shoot Down That North Korean Missile?”
Gather more data.
Another angle that I thought of would be not wanting to reveal info about our systems. What if then the Chinese decide to have some ELINT planes in the area.
When the ABM was being tested in the late 60’s early 70’s, the Soviets would have their big “fishing ships” near Kwajelein. Those fishing ships had a lot of antennae.
“You gotta know when to hold’em, Know when to fold’em, Know when to walk away, and know when to run.....”
The footprint is mapped and projected.
Release doesn’t occur until the coast phase, so the footprint is not infinite.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.