Sam Girod Gets 6 years in Prison for Herbal Salve

Redoubt News ^ | July 7, 2017 | Unknown

[Harmless Teddy Bear]

No, he got six years for making medically unverified claims for the salve that he made and sold.

You have to be very careful about what you claim your product does especially if it falls under "medical".

If I sell you my yogurt and say that it will heal your IBS then I have made a medical claim and could end up in jail.

If I sell you my yogurt and say it may help with the symptoms of IBS then I have NOT made a medical claim and I am in the clear.

Morally I doubt the guy was selling snake oil but the law does not make distinctions when it come to claims like that. Blame TR and the Pure Food and Drug Act.

[Albion Wilde]

“What are you in for?”

“Torture, rape and murder. You? What are you in for?”

“Salve. I made herbal salve.”

[Amendment10]

"These escharotics have been used for at least hundreds of years with effectiveness."

Thanks for reply Karl Spooner.

I’m not questioning the quality of Mr. Girod’s products. I’m questioning if Mr. Girod possibly sold his products in another state. Doing so would allow the feds to get their foot in the door with respect to his business under the Commerce Clause (1.8.3) imo.

But if Mr. Girod didn’t sell his products in another state, then other then the tortured interpretation of the Commerce Clause by FDR’s state sovereignty-ignoring activist justices imo, I don’t see where the feds have the constitutional authority to police his business.

[Karl Spooner]

Unless they changed the law, I don't think they do. This is from the JAMA website that is crying about it.

I view it as a close comparison to aspirin where everyone knew it worked, but it took them over 100 years to figure out why it worked. Also, aspirin is not a true herbal, it is synthesized compound found in willow bark.

"1994, legislation was passed prohibiting the FDA from overseeing the manufacturing, marketing, and distribution of herbal supplements. Alternative medications, once essentially banned by this agency, are now widely available as supplements and as such are largely unregulated."

http://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamadermatology/fullarticle/479092