The Challenging Life Of Oskar Schindler [No good deed goes unpunished]

The publication of Thomas Keneally’s book Schindler’s Ark (1982) and the release of the Steven Spielberg Oscar-winning film “Schindler’s List” (1993), made the basic story of Oskar Schindler widely known.

German industrialist, Nazi Party member, war profiteer, alcoholic, and shameless womanizer, Schindler (1908-1974) was both a cynical, greedy exploiter of slave workers and an authentic Holocaust hero best known for risking his life and spending his entire fortune during World War II to save over 1,200 Jews by employing them at his Krakow enamelware factory and protecting them by bribing German officials.

When the Nazis invaded Poland in 1939, the opportunistic businessman joined the Nazi Party. He gained ownership of an idle Jewish-owned enameled-goods factory close to the Jewish ghetto, Deutsch Emailwaren Fabrik, and, with the help of Itzhak Stern, his Jewish accountant, he obtained some 1,000 Jewish slave laborers.

Though initially motivated by money, Schindler was appalled by the Nazi murder of many of his Jewish workers and he thereafter used all his skills to protect his Schindlerjuden (“Schindler Jews”). He used the special status of his factory (“business essential to the war effort”) to arrange with Amon Göth, commandant of the Plaszow concentration camp, for 700 Jews to be transferred to an adjacent factory compound where he protected them.

In 1962 Schindler was declared one of the “righteous among the nations,” an honor awarded by Israel to non-Jews who saved Jews during the Holocaust at great personal risk, and he was the only (former) member of the Nazi Party ever invited to plant a tree at Jerusalem’s Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial.

Less well known than Schindler’s wartime heroics is his life after the war, which is actually a tragic tale of recurrent failure. He became the subject of substantial physical and verbal abuse because of the assistance he had provided to Jews during the war; in fact, after he was honored by Israel, Schindler’s German business partner terminated the partnership because “now it is clear that you are a friend of Jews and I will not work together with you any longer.”

His unambiguous condemnation and denunciation of German war criminals only served to exacerbate the enmity many Germans felt toward him. He was attacked with taunts of “You dirty Jew. They forgot to gas you” (Schindler, of course, was not Jewish), and workmen shouted “Too bad you didn’t burn with the Jews.”

In particular, Schindler received countless threats from former Nazis, including one from an attorney who, after unambiguously identifying himself as “an old Nazi,” noted Schindler’s visit to Israel and his support for Jews during the war and warned: “Because of your behavior, I have an eye on you, Herr Schindler.”

In one incident, one of his factory workers attacked him with an iron rod and, though he pressed charges, the post-Holocaust German authorities failed to take any action. When he punched out a factory worker who accused him of being a “Jew kisser,” he was hauled into court, charged with violence, and received a lecture from the judge on proper social behavior.

By the end of the war, Schindler had spent his vast fortune on bribes and black-market purchases of supplies for his workers and was virtually broke. Facing monumental financial difficulties and feeling understandably vulnerable in postwar Germany, he applied for an entry permit to the United States, but was turned down because he had served as a member of the Nazi Party. In 1949 he and his wife, Emilie, fled to Argentina where he settled down as a farmer. But when he went bankrupt in 1957, he abandoned Emilie (whom he would never see again).

Shown here is a card from a May 20, 1994 WIZO Gala Schindler Night in West Palm Beach, Florida, to honor Emilie Schindler. The card is signed by Emilie, Tom Keneally (author of Schindler’s Ark), and Jack Feigenbaum and Rena Schoenthal Fagen, surviving “Schindler Jews.” The event was the first time in 50 years that Emilie got to meet some of the people she and her husband had saved. She passed away on October 5, 2001 at age 93.

Schindler returned to Germany, where every subsequent business he tried, including a cement factory, also failed.front-page-110416-postcard

He was repeatedly saved from destitution only through funds provided by some of his “Schindlerjuden,” who had never forgotten him, and later thanks to a small pension he received from the West German government and stipends from Jewish organizations. He had serious health issues, including cardiovascular problems, and ultimately died of liver failure.

Exhibited here are excerpts from what is a truly remarkable and historic correspondence, one of only a handful of Schindler letters in existence. (It was typed on onionskin and therefore does not reproduce well here; I encourage readers interested in seeing all three pages of the letter to contact me and I will be happy to forward the entire scan.).

In the January 2, 1964 letter from Frankfurt am Main to Alfred Hermann, he discusses his difficult life after the war (translation from the German):

As you learned from German television, Channel 2, Mr. Wilfert intends to visit you in NY…. He wants to make a feature about you and some of our friends for television and produce material for your article in New York Herald Tribune…. It seems to be of no consequence that I am present. On December 30, 1963 at an exhibition at Frankfurt’s Paulskirche honoring the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, I had a short conversation with Mr. Wilfert (the exhibition coincides with the trial against Auschwitz guards in the City Hall next door)…. In your first article, and unfortunately I don’t read English, it supposedly says that I was stoned on the streets of Frankfurt. This is untrue and must be based on a translation error…. However, it is true that I was attacked with an iron rod in my factory by one of my workers. This happened in a suburb of Frankfurt in front of 10 witnesses, and I fell down the stairs into concrete blocks on the floor. The emphasis was not on the injuries I sustained but on the words that were spoken: “You dirty Jew. They forgot to gas you.” Half an hour later, I pressed charges with the Hanau police in front of witnesses, but nobody followed up on my complaint…. The police did nothing, and even my lawyer, Dr. Alexander Besser, advised me to let it go. At this time, I had been receiving medical treatments…due to my cardiovascular problems, and I didn’t want to deal with this issue…. I was boycotted and we experienced an unusually cold winter…. This was a new enterprise, we had no reserve assets and finally we received an eviction notice.

I have to reject the notion that these events could turn me into a martyr or that they were caused by political intrigue against me…. On the other hand, I cannot bear the notion that things beyond my control are being trivialized. And Mr. Wilfert was wrong when he stated that “You dirty Jew. They forgot to gas you” is a common saying in Frankfurt.

But I have to complain about a company I used to do business with. Witnesses were unavailable to Mr. Wilfert since they were sick or had been fired, but their attorney revealed himself as an “old Nazi” in front of witnesses. He commented on my visit to Israel and on my support for Jews during the war by saying: “Because of your behavior, I have an eye on you, Herr Schindler. I am an old Nazi.”… I informed my lawyer, and my co-owner, Herr von Wangenheim, about this incident. The result was that our business with them sunk to 10%.

After talking to me, Mr. Wilfert plans to find more witnesses to the assault on me and to my failed business. Today…my lawyer…informed me that he had told Mr. Wilfert, “They didn’t beat Schindler to death. He’s still alive.” This was only a small part of their conversation, and it might have been intended to be a compliment on my physical and mental strength, but it doesn’t help.

Dear Hermann, we have known each other now for 30 years, and unfortunately we’re getting older. We’ve always had the courage to face the truth, and it didn’t matter if personal, national or racial matters were involved. We have fought hard and honestly for our Golden Years, even though success was sometimes elusive. Therefore, I ask you to give the attached copy and newspaper article to your friend, the journalist, who was kind enough to publish your piece of writing. I want this gentleman to have an objective view of what happened. I want you, your family, and all of your friends to be healthy and successful, and I remain, as always,

The recipient of the letter, Alfred Hermann, was a Czech Jew who, according to his employment entry on Schindler’s List, was an accountant.

Otto Wilfert was a renowned German journalist and writer who served as editor for Second German Television (ZDF), a public service German television channel and one of the largest public broadcasters in Europe. He did in fact go on to write the feature article which Schindler discusses in our letter, “These Days: An Interview with Oscar Schindler.” He produced several television features detailing vicious attacks against Jews in Germany by neo-Nazis long after the Holocaust and he ran a documentary demonstrating that, as late as the 1970s, there was still strong support for Nazi ideology among the general German public.

Alexander Besser, whom Schindler cites as his lawyer, is himself an interesting character. After studying law at the Universities of Breslau and Berlin and earning his doctorate in law in 1927, he – along with every other Jewish lawyer in Germany – was disbarred in 1933. Beginning 1937, he worked in the Berlin Emigration Office of the Jewish Agency of Palestine, but was forced to flee to Eretz Yisrael in 1938, where he turned to journalism and worked for the magazine Hakidmah (“progress”) in Tel Aviv.

Upon his return to Germany in 1950, where he was admitted to the Frankfurt bar, he became a renowned radio and television commentator and served as a journalist for the General Weekly of the Jews in Germany. Besser represented Schindler in a broad range of matters, including the purchases of several businesses as well as various bankruptcy proceedings. It’s interesting to note that Schindler not only turned to a Jewish lawyer to assist him with his many legal issues but to one with a significant public profile as a German Jew.

Finally, public exhibitions and memorials in Germany dealing with the Holocaust were always controversial, a manifestation of Germany’s struggle to confront its terrible Nazi legacy. The first such event, to which Schindler refers in our correspondence, was the Warsaw Ghetto Exhibition at the Frankfurt Paulskirche, which opened on November 23, 1963, ran through January 1964, and drew 61,000 visitors.

As Schindler notes, the exhibition opened in Frankfurt during the trial of several former Auschwitz camp guards. In fact, highlighting the trial was, at least in part, an important objective of the creators of the exhibition, who deliberately included contemporary photographs of the Nazi defendants entering the courthouse and excerpts from the prosecution’s indictment.

The exhibition designers depicted the Holocaust as the logical result of the Nazi seizure of power in 1933 and the gradual dehumanization of Jews. The underlying theme they sought to convey was that immoral ideas inexorably lead to evil actions. However, the exhibition was broadly criticized for emphasizing universal lessons about victimization, and for presenting a generic characterization of the victims of National Socialism, when in fact the Nazis’ primary victims were Jews and the unambiguous goal of the Third Reich was the total annihilation of the Jewish people.

In the Frankfurt Auschwitz trials, which attracted considerable publicity in Germany, 22 defendants were charged under German criminal law – not on the legal definition of crimes against humanity as then recognized by international law – for their roles as lower-level officials at Auschwitz. Though the defendants were convicted, the trial was considered by many to be a failure because the media treated the accused as sick, deviant monsters, which enabled Germans to view the defendants as different from “normal Germans” – such as themselves.

Schindler died in Germany on October 9, 1974, at age 66 – about 10 years after he wrote our letter. As he had requested, he was buried in Jerusalem.

His great legacy is attested to by the more than 7,000 descendants of the “Schindler Jews” who are alive today.

“German industrialist, Nazi Party member, war profiteer, alcoholic, and shameless womanizer”

I always laugh at the term “womanizer”. It implies that helpless innocent women are hypnotized by men into doing things they would NEVER dream of.

He said, rather, that it was immoral for Germans to reproduce, since they were historically such warmongers and racists.

And now they've imported exactly that to replace themselves.

They would have done better to stand pat. Would that his 20yo version could have seen the present situation...where is a time machine when you need one?

“They can never atone for their crimes nor will they ever recover the irreplaceable genetic loss of their best stock between 1914-1945. The results insanity of the Kaiser and Hitler can never be forgotten or reversed.”

That’s the same collective guilt mentality that allowed the Germans to murder Jews. The German people didn’t commit crimes, individuals did. A German today has zero guilt they should carry. And the genetic loss of their best stock? You must be kidding. The mass murderers on the WWII German military were not the best stock.
The final error in that was to join the German military of WWI with WWII, and of the Kaiser with Hitler. They could not be more opposite.
In WWI Germany was not evil or a cause of the War. Britain carries more blame than Germany in WWI. The German soldier in WWI had the right to vote, the average Brit did not. The average Russian soldier was fighting for the last absolute monarchy. (in the war to make the world safe for democracy)

The end of Schindler's List suggested that he had a difficult life after the war.It would appear that booze might have been one of the main problems.It's not difficult to imagine how anyone,including Schindler,who had suffered,or seen suffering,during WWII would turn to booze to kill the pain.Although he was clearly an imperfect man my guess is that he didn't have a huge problem at The Pearly Gates.

“I called it “sick, irrational inherited guilt”. I urged him not to do anything so destructive and drastic.?”

Wonderful story. True to German friends I have known. And good for you. Its the antithesis of Americanism that the descendants are also guilty of the crimes of the father. Good for you.
And nice seeing you here.

Well, now if someone drugs a woman into a stupor, that’s a different kettle of fish. That’s just a Cosby rapist. I was speaking of the ones who use charm and blarney to get the women.
I just always roll my eyes that the objects of their attention are helpless waifs before his onslaught of BS.

Thanks for the post. I tried to find the “Leanings” article that Peter Egan wrote about Schindler shortly after the book came out and post a link to it but could not find it online. And yes, we do look at life differently, wouldn’t have it any other way.

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.