Posted on 01/07/2016 5:15:13 AM PST by Kaslin

"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." -- Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution
In 2008, the Supreme Court laid to rest the once-simmering dispute over the meaning of the Second Amendment. In an opinion written by Justice Antonin Scalia, the court articulated the modern existence of the ancient right to keep and bear arms as a pre-political right.
A pre-political right is one that pre-exists the political order that was created to protect it. Thus, the court held, the origins of this right are the ancient and persistent traditions of free peoples and their natural inclinations to self-defense.
The court also characterized the right as fundamental. That puts it in the highest category of rights protected by the Bill of Rights. Though the origins of this right are from an era well before guns existed, the textual language in the amendment -- "Arms" -- makes clear, the court ruled, the intention of the Framers that its continuing purpose should be to recognize the right of people to keep and use the same level of technologically available arms that might be used against them.
That, in a nutshell, is the history, theory and purpose of the amendment as the modern Supreme Court has found them to be. But as we have seen, the constitutional guarantees that were written to keep the government from interfering with our rights are only as viable as is the fidelity to the Constitution of those in whose hands we have reposed it for safekeeping.
In our system, principal among those are the hands of the president; and sadly, today we have a president seriously lacking in this fidelity. And that lack is salient when it comes to the Second Amendment.
Earlier this week, President Barack Obama announced that he will sign executive orders that expand the size and scope of federal monitoring of the acquisition and use of guns -- traditionally a matter left to the states -- and he will interpret the laws in novel ways, establish rules and impose obligations that Congress rejected, and prosecute those who defy his new system.
The president has very little room to issue executive orders on guns because the congressional legislation in this area is so extensive, detailed and clear. In addition to ordering your doctor to report to the Department of Homeland Security any mention you may make to the doctor of guns in your home, the president has decreed on his own and against the articulated will of Congress the obligation of all people who transfer any gun to any other person to obtain a federal gun dealer license. This is among the most cumbersome and burdensome licenses to obtain.
He has also decreed that any licensee who fails to perform a background check on the person to whom the licensee has transferred a gun shall be guilty of a felony. Give a BB gun to your nephew on his 16th birthday without a federal license and you can go to prison.
Can the president do that? In a word: No.
Under our system of government, only Congress can write federal laws and establish crimes. The president is on particularly thin constitutional ice here because his allies in Congress have proposed this very procedure as an amendment to existing law, and Congress has expressly rejected those proposals.
The president is without authority to negate the congressional will, and any attempt to do so will be invalidated by the courts. As well, by defining what an occasional seller is, beyond the congressional definition or the plain meaning of the words, the president is essentially interpreting the law, a job reserved for the courts.
By requiring physicians to report conversations with their patients about guns to the DHS, the president will be encouraging them to invade the physician-patient privilege; and I suspect that most doctors will ignore him.
Under the Constitution, fundamental liberties (speech, a free press, worship, self-defense, travel and privacy, to name a few) are accorded the highest protection from governmental intrusion. One can only lose a fundamental right by intentionally giving it up or via due process (a jury trial resulting in a conviction for criminal behavior). The president -- whose support for the right to keep and bear arms is limited to the military, the police and his own heavily armed body guards -- is happy to begin a slippery slope down into the dark hole of totalitarianism, whereby he or a future president can negate liberties if he hates or fears the exercising of them.
We still have a Constitution in America. Under the Constitution, Congress writes the laws, the president enforces them, and the courts interpret them. The president can no more write his own laws or impose his own interpretations upon pre-existing laws than Congress or the courts can command the military.
As troubling as this turn of events is, it is not surprising. The president is a progressive, and the ideology of progressivism is anathema to self-help or individualism. He really believes that the government can care for us better than we can care for ourselves.
Yet he ignores recent history. Any attempt to make it more difficult for people to keep and bear arms not only violates the fundamental liberty of those people but also jeopardizes the safety of us all. Add to this the progressive tendency to use government to establish no-gun zones and you have the recipe for disaster we have recently witnessed. All of the recent mass killings in America -- from Columbine to San Bernardino -- have occurred in no-gun zones, where crazies and terror-minded murderers can shoot with abandon.
That is, until someone arrives with a gun and shoots back. Then the killer flees or is injured or dies -- and the killing stops.
As the libs are so fond of saying: “IT IS THE LAW OF THE LAND”.
Progressive hypocrisy regarding 2A is absolute and rampant. Hillary has been called to put her safety where she demands others be put, by disarming her phalanx of personal pretorians. The same must now be demanded of Obama, the boy king.
Yes
If the Congress cannot, or will not, check the actions of a rogue President, then it falls to We the People to protect our natural rights.
Maybe the second amendment covers no laws to control guns....but I think the administration has discovered that you can invent regulation (without any Congressional involvement) which makes all gun users potentially a dealer, and they can impede and discriminate against all dealers because it’s a commerce thing for them to manage.
Obama don’t need no steenkin’ constitution.
Where is our Cromwell? Our New Model Army? We know who’s playing the role of Charles I.
Without exception, the Congressional Republican response to an illegal usurpation by Obama is to express sorrow and regret and unhappiness over the situation.
Now when Trump says that there should be a moratorium on Muslim immigration to the United States for national security reasons, Ryan marches out with clear-eyed fury and condemnation. “That’s not conservatism!!!!!”
We already have No Knock Searches, 4th amendment?
Restrictions on speech, ie. Gays, and now the push to restrict criticism of Islam. 1st amendment.
The religion portion crushed long ago.
Restrictions on gatherings.
So what’s the problem with a little 2nd amendment stomping. /s
I’ll bet almost all citizens younger than about 40 have never read or had a class on the Constitution.
Completely ignorant as to what is the government’s role and restrictions in federal laws.
Unlike my generation that spent weeks studying it in high school.
As a BA in English, let me point out something regarding the literal meaning of the second amendment. Irrespective of the meaning of “regulated” in the 18th century, it is only the militia that is subject to such regulation. The keeping and bearing of arms by the people are specifically removed from government infringement. Nowhere in the wording of the amendment is there a logical or grammatical connection drawn between the militia and the peoples’ arms.
As written, the second amendment prohibits ANY infringement by the government on the keeping and bearing of arms by the people.
All the BS on odumbo’s latest EO to tighten gun control would be null and void if the congress idiots would have just DEFUNDED the whole thing, They, (congress) are just as guilty of this tyranny as odumbo is. Time to clean then out.
We homeschool. It’s been covered.
‘But as we have seen, the constitutional guarantees that were written to keep the government from interfering with our rights are only as viable as is the fidelity to the Constitution of those in whose hands we have reposed it for safekeeping.’
This is the prime reason this right was enumerated. The govt is NEVER a reliable protector of our rights, ever. We are given the task of overseeing govt even to the point of bearing arms against it to preserve those rights.
That made me smile. My hats off to you for taking responsibility for your childrens education. :)
The document, along with the Dec of Independence are on our wall in our family room. The documents surround a picture of Pres Reagan speaking in front of the Bradenburg Gate. I like your tagline btw :)
This whole thing is just a stunt by a lameduck loser who is trying to stay relevant. Its illegal and will be struck down by a judge in a month or so.
I wouldn’t give OFail’s illegal EO even a moment of thougt much less abide by it.
"This country, with its institutions, belongs to the people who inhabit it. Whenever they shall grow weary of the existing government, they can exercise their constitutional right of amending it, or exercise their revolutionary right to overthrow it." --Abraham Lincoln
The Administration HAS discovered that.
And, apparently, discovered that it cannot be strained for abuse any further.
Construing ALL private sales as “business” is a legal non-starter. They don’t want to defend that stance in court.
The best they can do is construe “business” as “any activity colloquially resembling & perceived as ‘business’”, which is exactly how it has been construed.
The ONLY conceivable change is to let those who _want_ to be construed as “business” do so, by ending the long-standing pogrom against “kitchen table dealers” and issuing an FFL to anyone who duly asks for one. This is, AFAIK, the only meaningful change coming from the Obama’s speech.
The unintended consequence of that one change - issuing an FFL to practically anyone who asks for one (background check & tax satisfied) - is that lots of options re-open for those willing to register as an FFL, restoring the benefits of “kitchen table FFL” (eviscerated under Clinton) and even improved access to “Class III” armaments. The BATFE may be inundated with FFL requests now, and under the Administration’s proffered intentions may have great difficulty denying applicants.
“Its illegal and will be struck down by a judge in a month or so.”
WHAT is illegal? His speech was sound and fury signifying nothing. There is no new “it”. At worst, doctors may tattle on patients (who will fast learn to not discuss armaments with doctors). At best, he ended Clinton’s evisceration of the “kitchen table FFL” subculture and has handed us broad new (if registered) access to weapons previously difficult to come by.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.