Posted on 01/06/2016 1:31:56 PM PST by Isara
Years ago, Donald Trump forced Barack Obama to produce his birth certificate by elevating questions of his birthplace to front-page news. Now he's turned his guns on leading challenger Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX), suggesting that his birth in Canada makes him ineligible for the presidency. In an interview, Trump said that Cruz's birth was a "very precarious" problem: "Republicans are going to have to ask themselves the question: 'Do we want a candidate who could be tied up in court for two years?' That'd be a big problem."
Trump supporter Ann Coulter agrees:
|
NYT: Cruz was born outside the U.S. to 1 American parent: "Under the Constitution this makes him a 'natural born citizen.'" Absolutely false - Ann Coulter (@AnnCoulter) January 6, 2016 |
This is clearly a desperate play by Trump to rip back support from Cruz. Back in September, when Cruz was but a glimmer in Trump's polling data, Trump dismissed birther questions on ABC News: "I hear it was checked out by every attorney and every which way and I understand Ted is in fine shape." That was months after declaring Cruz's birthplace "a stumbling block."
So Trump flip-flops on this issue, too.
But for those wondering, he's likely wrong on the legal side.
Here are the facts.
The provision of the Constitution in question is Article II, Section 1, Clause 5:
No Person except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of the United States, at the time of the Adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the Office of President; neither shall any Person be eligible to that Office who shall not have attained to the Age of thirty five Years, and been fourteen Years a Resident within the United States.
Cruz's mother was born in Delaware, his father in Cuba. Cruz was born in 1970 in Calgary, Canada.
So, what does it mean to be a "natural born citizen"?
The goal of the "natural born citizen" clause was to prevent "all chances for ambitious foreigners, who might otherwise be intriguing for the office," according to Justice Story. So, what did the clause mean practically?
Under British law preceding American law, "natural born" meant both jus soli and jus sanguinis. Jus soli means that you are a citizen if born within the territory of the country. Jus sanguinis means that you are a citizen if one of your parents is a citizen. In its 1790 naturalization statute, the United States re-enshrined this principle, stating, "the children of citizens of the United States, that may be born beyond the sea, or out of the limits of the United States, shall be considered as natural born citizens." But whether the Constitution embraces the same language remains a semi-open question upon which the Supreme Court has not openly ruled.
The only way Cruz's eligibility would arise is if Trump actually sued to keep Cruz off the ballot, or if a state did so. Neither seems likely.
Final word to Cruz:
|
My response to @realDonaldTrump calling into question my natural-born citizenship? Jump the Shark! - Ted Cruz (@tedcruz) January 5, 2016 |
Years ago, Donald Trump forced Barack Obama to produce his birth certificate by elevating questions of his birthplace to front-page news.
Actually Ben Trump forced him to produce a fraudulent document that resembled a real birth certificate.
I guess flip flopping is only detrimental when Democrats like John Kerry do it.
Shapiro should say that to Nguyen who has a US citizen father who lost his deportation Supreme Court case.
I hate this twisting of the constitution and presidential eligibility, created by the twisted reasoning that let Obama take office. The constitution clearly says, that the president must be at least 35 years old, be born on American soil, both parents must be American, and have lived in the US for the last 14 years.
What are we going to say next? The president does not have to be at least 35 years old? Or that he never had to live in the US?
Yes, Cruz is a citizen, no question about it. But he, Rubio, Jindhal, or Obama meet the constitutional qualifications.
It seems that many conservatives have a double standard where the constitution is concerned, if constitutional mandates inconvenience us, toss the constitution, but by no means may the liberals do it.
Either we stick to the constitution or we do not. I’m just not going to vote for Cruz, even though I like him very much, he is not qualified to be president and I think we need to start taking the constitution seriously, in plain language, or we have lost. And we did it to ourselves, the left did not do it.
Wrong. Trump's point was that the Democrats would sue.
But that still leaves the problem of the president’s age (at least 35) and whether he has lived the last 14 years in the USA. Are those qualifications to be disregarded also? Can we pick and choose what parts of the constitution we like? Do we ignore the constitution because we like Cruz or Rubio or Obama?
And by the way, when that naturalization act that you referred to was passed, the wife automatically lost her citizenship upon her marriage to a foreigner, and became a citizen of his country; her children were not American citizens. So if you are going to harken back to law, you still have a problem.
Kenyan Sunday Standard, electronic edition, of June 27, 2004

It says no such thing. It says he must be a natural born citizen, and you are construing that to mean what you believe it means. What you believe is at odds with what the Congress in 1790, many of whom were the same people who wrote the constitution, clarified by statute.
The Act also establishes the United States citizenship of certain children of citizens, born abroad, without the need for naturalization: "the children of citizens of the United States that may be born beyond Sea, or out of the limits of the United States, shall be considered as natural born Citizens."
The Constitution does not clearly state that. It says no such thing remotely resembling that. If you would like to post excerpts from the Constitution to make your arguments it is easy enough to do. Making up what the Constitution says is just silly.
The ANN COULTER who claimed Obama was natural born and demanded the right keep their mouths shut about it or look like fools.....right? Obama’s mother was under-age to confer citizenship on him when he was born, so if Obama is natural-born Ted is WAY more than eligible.
There appears to be some issues:
To: Behind the Blue Wall
The “original” SR511 definition of NBC ( http://www.leahy.senate.gov/press/the-introduction-of-a-senate-resolution ) signed by Obama, Clinton, Leahy, Coburn, Webb and McCaskill and verified by Chertoff, states very plainly that NBC means born in the USA of two US citizen parents. The SR511 that Congress vetted McCain with ( https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/110/sres511/text ) is a watered down version but still states TWO US CITIZENS.
There is a reason Leahy has kept the original version on his website all these years.
104 posted on 1/6/2016 11:59:46 AM by bgill (CDC site, “We still do not know exactly how people are infected with Ebola”)
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/3380307/posts?page=104#104
To: Wissa
“Don’t you think it would be better for Cruz to put all the documentation and facts out there”
Don’t hold your breath, looks like Cruz is going the Obama route
“At present, all FOIA (Freedom of Information Act) requests filed in search of any U.S. citizenship documents to confirm the true official U.S. citizenship status of Ted Cruz have been denied access. All citizenship records for Ted Cruz are sealed unless and until Ted Cruz agrees to allow any such records to be released by either U.S. or Canadian agencies.”
http://www.newswithviews.com/JBWilliams/williams317.htm
At the tail end of the article 6 paragraphs before the end.
115 posted on 1/6/2016 12:26:27 PM by jpsb
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/3380307/posts?page=115#115
Making up what you want it to say is just as silly.
I think what Trump is alluding to is the chance Democrats will file suit and tie up the nomination.
It needs to be settled.
This issue is one thing that really opened my eyes this last seven years. There are a whole lot of people who do not know what the F*** they are talking about.
Most people who opine on this issue are just like "the Blind men and the Elephant."
And so these men of Indostan
Disputed loud and long,
Each in his own opinion
Exceeding stiff and strong,
Though each was partly in the right,
And all were in the wrong!
The convoluted rationalizations invoked to declare Cruz a NBC are troubling indeed.
His mother was a citizen so then he is one. OK.
His father was a not a citizen so then he is also a foreigner. Not OK.
The same logic is dumped when it does not favor the Cruz supporters.
If the Founders did not mean to exclude the children of foreigners from the office of President then what did they mean by the requirement?
Crickets.
Thanks.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.