[JohnBovenmyer]

Jimmy did it by state, not by religion. At least to some that is a significant difference.

[Red Badger]

Easy, just ban all immigration from muslim majority countries.....................

[Auntie Dem]

Jimmy did it by state, not by religion. At least to some that is a significant difference.

Rephrased slightly: Jimmy did it by tagging a group with certain identifying characteristics, traits or attitudes, that were a threat to the security of the U.S. In addition, it has been argued that islam is a political movement--not a religion--and therefore the equivalent of a state. Isn't that what a Caliphate is?