Nope, she doesn’t win. She loses...her audience. Which was what this was all about.
The consequences of her behavior still happen, in fact they are actually worse because she continues to refuse to follow instructions. Not only that, she ends up looking silly.
She might retain her audience.
Teacher/staff say “alright everybody, since she’s being disruptive and refusing to leave, we’re all going to a different room” ... and given the choice between standing with homie or whitey, most/all stay. Now what?
She’s not playing by your axioms. Making everyone else move is a win. Anyone who stays with her increases that win.
Consequences? WTF does she care about consequences?
Oh no. This was about a battle of wills, a refusal of a sizeable portion of youth to accept the word "no."
This attitude is learned and reinforced at home, that you are not subject to authority and that being told " no" is a sign of disrespect.
This is not the acting out of some suburban teen.
does not work like that.
The whole class has to leave because of her, no.
No witnesses for her to make a story up would have happened, plus she would have said look at me and been the center of attention at the school how she rebelled,