I like Rudy and think he did a fine job (from what I have read). Especially during 911. The right man at the right time.
Disclaimer: I do not live nor have I ever been to NY...although I would like to go on New Years Eve if I could get a posh hotel room to watch the festivities. Fat chance, berdie!!
I’ve been to NYC a few times and was underwhelmed. These days it’s a commie liberal paradise. No way would I travel there now.