Posted on 10/14/2015 1:41:34 PM PDT by Republicanprofessor
As I drifted off to sleep to the first Democratic debate last night, I realized that all of these candidates are 1) preaching to the choir and 2) competing to see who can re-package traditional Democratic ideas in the most appealing way. “I’ll give more freebies than you….free college, free health care” etc. There was little contesting of those ideas. No one considered who would pay for such socialism, apart from “the rich.” Republicans need to directly challenge these ideas.
The same held true for the Republican debates….most of the same ideas (control of immigration, stronger foreign policy etc.) are also shared by many of the candidates. They, too, may be preaching to the choir, since how many people really watch the debates of the candidates of the opposite party? How many people even read or listen to ideas from the other side? It is much more comforting to read postings that reinforce how you feel.
So why don’t we have the first bi-partisan debate with Sanders and Clinton side by side with Trump, Carson, Fiorina, Cruz, Rubio and/or Jeb? It would be much more interesting to see this kind of a debate of ideas than the usual, predetermined debates. And many would tune in to see this, especially with Trump in the race. It would also test our candidates nicely in terms of policies, ideas and presentation, especially against the opposing party. How great it would be to do this before the first primaries! We might even have more informed voters.
Such a bi-partisan debate format would be a great forum to present conservative ideas to the entire electorate. Furthermore, these ideas need to be presented forcefully, throughout the next year, to all constituencies, including those that the GOP may have ignored in the past: millennials, Hispanics, African-Americans and women. Having a bi-partisan debate would put our ideas into clearer contrast with the Democrats and, I hope, encourage thought by all. I think such a debate would be fascinating, especially if it occurred before any of the primaries. Can you imagine how lively the foreign policy discussion could be? Would Hillary have the guts to accept the challenge from the GOP to debate before the primaries? Let’s invite her and see…..
“So why don’t we have the first bi-partisan debate with Sanders and Clinton side by side with Trump, Carson, Fiorina, Cruz, Rubio and/or Jeb? “
You just answered your own question.
Because the Democratic candidates won’t fair well in the real rough and tumble when they don’t know the questions in advance and have canned focus tested answers.
Great idea.
My own is that each candidate selects a debate moderator to ask the questions.
For example Ted Cruz might ask Dick Cheney to be a moderator.
MILEY CYRUS TO PERFORM ALL NUDE CONCERT
Ah , what about
Yes, and have Rush Limbaugh as the mediator! That would be well worth watching!
Great idea!
Little chance of it happening.
Sort of like having the Republican primaries sequenced from the greatest R margin in the 2012 POTUS election to the least.
Well, because it ain’t gonna happen.
“Yes, and have Rush Limbaugh as the mediator! That would be well worth watching!”
I haven’t owned a TV since the O’jay trial. But I would rush out and buy one for that debate!
So why don’t we have the first bi-partisan debate
*************
Who is we? The current political parties control their own debates. I know of know entity
that has the control over each of them so as to mandate they have a debate with a couple
of candidates from each party.
The Commission on Presidential Debates will be invovled once the nominees are selected.
http://www.debates.org/index.php?page=overview
They’re looking for ways to raise ratings for Dem Debates.
No, thanks.
HELL NO!
Not only that, it helps them determine who’s best against our candidates on the fly.
Why should we aid that?
The Republicans yell at each other. The Democrats are boring and sing kumbuya all night. There’s was boring, but ours was a circus. The two cannot mesh.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.