Posted on 07/05/2014 4:53:33 AM PDT by Kaslin
Gentlemen, Herbert Hoover told visiting dignitaries in June of 1930, you have come six weeks too late. The Depression, he declared, was over. Sadly, for him and for the country, he wasnt correct.
Still, sometimes you do arrive too late and miss all the action. Take the group of immigration reform activists who crashed Rep. Eric Cantors victory party in June. What do we want? Immigration reform! When do we want it? Now! they chanted. Two problems: Cantor had, like Elvis, already left the building. And because of the primary results, the former House Majority Leader will be leaving Congress in January.
Even if Cantor had prevailed at the ballot box, this would have been an odd protest. His defeat was, at least partly, because he was working to push through a comprehensive immigration reform measure.
Cantor spoke about immigration last year, in the midst of a long speech at the American Enterprise Institute. He touched on many excellent ideas over the course of that speech: Education reform that favors students rather than teacher unions. Reducing regulations to make new, better medicines available more quickly. Simplifying the tax code.
But he also addressed immigration.
A good place to start is with the kids, he announced. It is time to provide an opportunity for legal residence and citizenship for those who were brought to this country as children and who know no other home.
Well, that sounds an awful lot like the DREAM Act, which has been introduced some 30 times in several Congresses but never approved. President Obama, vastly overstepping his constitutional bounds, basically enacted such a policy via executive fiat in 2012. He ordered the Department of Homeland Security to defer deportation proceedings against an estimated 1.7 million illegal aliens.
The President himself had admitted that he doesnt have the constitutional authority to implement the DREAM Act: The idea of doing things on my own is very tempting, I promise you, not just on immigration reform. But thats not how our system works. Thats not how our democracy functions, he told Hispanic activists in 2011. But 2012 was an election year, and the move generated some good PR.
The problem with this approach is that its starting at the wrong end.
Dealing with children whove been brought here illegally is always going to be one of our countrys most difficult problems. So instead of getting bogged down on that while trying to pass comprehensive reform, lawmakers should start where theres wide agreement: close the borders. Crack down on people working illegally. Force illegals to tag up in their home country before they can return here.
After these less controversial problems are solved, lawmakers could then turn to the more difficult problems, such as what to do with the kids.
Instead, were dealing with the fallout of Obamas unilateral actions.
Between 2008 and 2011, the number of children landing in the custody of Refugee Resettlement fluctuated between 6,000 and 7,500 per year FOX reports. In 2012 border agents apprehended 13,625 unaccompanied children and that number surged even more -- to 24,668 -- last year. AsThe Economist reports, A leaked border-agency memo based on interviews with 230 women and children apprehended in the Rio Grande Valley concluded that they had crossed the border mainly because they expected to be allowed to stay. So were making the most contentious problem worse, instead of solving the problems we generally agree about.
Now the president is again vowing action. The only thing I can't do is stand by and do nothing, he says. So hes asking Congress (what a concept!) for more money for detention facilities and more judges to speed the processing of those whove been caught here. Its a start.
The United States is a nation of immigrants. We have always welcomed the rest of the world, and we will continue to do so. But it must be done on our terms, and to our benefit. Thats where immigration reform needs to start.
Taking reasonable steps that enjoy overwhelming approval would be far easier than trying to enact comprehensive reform. Lawmakers could the border under control. But they have to stop making the perfect (comprehensive reform) the enemy of the good.
Your discussion is fine but it won’t fit on an attention-getting 3X5 postcard to mail to your legislators. First, let’s get their minds right. Then, we can work out the details.
You can fit a few of the points I made on a 3x5 card. And the reality is that our legislators know all of this. I say that advisedly lobbying on the Hill on this issue.
That is exactly what Ronald Reagan and the Democrats promised to do after the Reagan Amnesty, in 1986, 28 years ago!
Reagan didn't do it.
George H.W. Bush didn't do it.
George W. Bush didn't do it.
In fact, “W” tried to shove the Bush-McCain Amnesty down our throats in 2006.
Then, his partner in political crime, John McCain, was nominated for president in 2008, by the same freaking Republicans who stopped Amnesty in 2006!
The bitter fruit of legal immigration is about to be served to the Republican Party.
Since the Reagan Amnesty in 1986, the Democrat Party has legally imported 20 million new Socialist voters.
Today, nationally, the Democrats have enough LEGAL voters to beat us any time they like.
All they need to do is get their core voting blocs to the polls - and in 2014, they will.
Republicans will NOT win the Senate in 2014.
Republicans will NOT win the White House in 2016.
And in 2022, after Congressional redistricting, we will lose the House of Representatives.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.