Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: NFHale
I've read three books on Custer in the last year including SOTMS. The most recent was by Robert Upton "Cavalier In Bucksin" which was also a big coffee-table type book. Custer was not the villain recently portrayed by leftist moviemakers and historians. Neither was he deserving of unstinted praise. He was interested in glory and money, and he achieved a measure of the first.

But regarding his death, according to Utley, Custer's battle plans were not unsound. He simply didn't achieve the coordinating effect he wanted from Reno and Benteen. And to be fair, all the previous, similar battle plans had worked. But this time "Custer's luck" ran out. Custer was always a big risk taker, and fortunate to survive the Civil War. But if Benteen (who hated Custer) had not been slow and Reno not retreated at the first sign of difficulty, Custer might have won that engagement.

80 posted on 08/19/2013 6:17:54 AM PDT by driftless2
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 76 | View Replies ]


To: driftless2

“...He was interested in glory and money, and he achieved a measure of the first. ...”

He was “a man of his age”, so to speak. No less than a Phil Sheridan, or a William T. Sherman, or Nelson Bearcoat Miles. They were Americans first, and everything else second, and believed in expanding (and protecting) the borders of our nation to the best of their abilities.

“...Custer’s battle plans were not unsound...”
I read that he had two Gatlings available to him for use, but he left them behind, fearing they would slow him down.

And as for Reno and Benteen, yeah, they had no for each other OR for Custer. I get the impression, though, that even if both of their respective columns would have been able to get to him, all that would resulted would be a pile of MORE blue-clad bodies. There were one hell of a lot of Indian warriors there.

Would the Gatlings have been game-changers??? I don’t know; i think the indians were savvy enough by that time that they would simply targeted the crew-served weapons immediately and taken them out of the fight.

Who knows... one of the great “What Ifs” of American history...


82 posted on 08/19/2013 6:46:36 AM PDT by NFHale (The Second Amendment - By Any Means Necessary.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 80 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson