The only "circular arguments" I've seen here are the ones you folks post.
Jay Redhawk: "Some people just do not have the ability to understand philosophical principles and logic.
They will never get it and will always be on the wrong side of reality and history."
Those would be your typical Pro-Confederate Lost Causers.
I asked two questions, neither of which you addressed. No doubt the DC empire will have its loyalists. Following orders are you?