Plus, the ideal Catwoman needs to be 1) sexy as hell, 2) able to stand up head-to-head to male characters and kick their ass. Hathaway utterly fails category #2. (and she did do a decent job stepping into Barbara Feldon's shoes as Agent 99 in the Get Smart movie)
I was never that big on Michelle Pfeiffer, anyhow. I’m sorta torn on Hathaway. Sometimes she is hot, sometimes she’s a dork.