None of that matters. Kennedy was set to strike the entire law... roberts violated his oath of office and rewrote the law to allow it to stand... and he legislated from the bench in violation of the Constitution... which was nullified yesterday by this decision. No spin can remove the fact that the rule of law and the US Constitution no longer supply any protections or guide any of our laws... this decision put us firmly into a post Constitutional era.
LLS
It does matter
If it is a tax it is a tax no matter what they called it
But that doesn’t mean that there still weren’t aspects that weren’t unconstitutional —I would like to see arguments from that facet—in other words yes it is a tax but it is still unconstitutional because————————
Did Scalia present that rational in his dissent —I don’t know I am asking or did he say it wasn’t a tax