Posted on 06/27/2012 4:43:17 AM PDT by marktwain
A single internal Department of Justice email could be the smoking-gun document in the Operation Fast and Furious scandal if it turns out to contain what congressional investigators have said it does.
The document would establish that wiretap application documents show senior DOJ officials knew about and approved the gunwalking tactic in Fast and Furious. This is the opposite of what Attorney General Eric Holder and House oversight committee ranking Democratic member Rep. Elijah Cummings have claimed.
It appears that email would also prove senior DOJ officials, likely including Holder himself, knew in March 2011 that a Feb. 4, 2011 letter from the DOJ to Iowa Republican Sen. Chuck Grassley falsely denied guns were permitted to walk into Mexico. The DOJ allowed that false letter to stand for nine more months, only withdrawing it in December 2011.
During the June 24 broadcast of Fox News Sunday, House oversight committee chairman Rep. Darrell Issa cited the email as a good example of a specific document his committee knows Holder is hiding from Congress.
The ATF director, Kenneth Melson, sent an e-mail. And he had said to us in sworn testimony that, in fact, he had concerns, Issa said. And we want to see that e-mail because thats an example where he was saying, if we believe his sworn testimony, that guns walked. And he said it shortly after February 4, and [on] July 4. When he told us that, we began asking for that document.
But the details of it surfaced first when Grassley mentioned it for the first time publicly during a June 12 Senate Judiciary Committee hearing where Holder was testifying.
He [Melson] immediately sent an email warning others, back off the letter to Sen. Grassley in light of the information in the affidavits, Grassley explained.
Ken Melson, now the former acting director of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, purportedly sent that email to several DOJ leaders in March 2011. According to Grassley, Melson wrote that he had reviewed the wiretap applications the same documents Cummings and Holder claim do not show senior DOJ officials knew of or approved gunwalking tactics in Fast and Furious.
ATF Acting Director Kenneth Melson described reading those same wiretap affidavits in March of last year, Grassley told Holder during the Senate hearing. He said he was alarmed that the information in the affidavits contradicted the public denial to Congress.
It appears Republican congressional investigators first learned of the Melson emails existence on July 4, 2011, when Melson chose to give a lengthy deposition on Fast and Furious without DOJ and ATF lawyers present. Grassley told Holder during the Senate hearing that congressional investigators first requested that the DOJ provide Congress with that email during July 2011, shortly after Melson made his then-secret trip across town to Capitol Hill.
The wiretap documents themselves are under federal court seal, leaving Grassley and Issa to tussle with Holder and Cumming about what they might show. Issa has said a whistleblower provided copies to his committee.
Holder has declined to ask the federal judge who sealed them to unseal them. The March 2011 Melson email, then, may be the only legal way without violating a court order to document the agreement of some senior Obama administration members with Issas and Grassleys characterizations of the documents.
Melsons email could also prove that although senior DOJ officials knew in March 2011 that the Feb. 4, 2011 letter was false, they chose to continue misleading Congress with gunwalking denials for several months.
We need to see it [the email] to corroborate his testimony, Grassley said during the June 12 hearing. But the Department is withholding that email along with every other document after Feb. 4, 2011.
Grassley pressed Holder on the question of how DOJ had the authority to withhold Melsons email from Congress, a full week before President Obama indicated that he would invoke executive privilege to shield requested documents. At that time, Holder claimed the Melson email would not be protected by executive privilege.
On what legal ground are you withholding that email? He asked. The president cant claim executive privilege to withhold that email, is that correct?
Well, let me just say this: We have reached out to Chairman Issa to work our way through these issues, Holder filibustered. We have had sporadic contacts and we are prepared to make I am prepared to make compromises with regard to the documents that can be made available. There is a basis for withholding these documents if they deal with the deliberative
But not on executive privilege? Grassley interrupted.
No, Holder responded.
Holder spokeswoman Tracy Schmaler wouldnt answer when The Daily Caller asked her if the DOJ was planning to provide the Melson email to Congress.
My guess is quite a bit.
Remember, when Melson appeared before Issa et al on 7/4/11 it was with his own atty......NOT a DOJ atty. Melson could very well be the Al Butterfield of this mess. Whether Issa and/or Boehner choose to bring EVERYTHING into the light of day however, remains to be seen. Since it is barely hinted at that F&F was instituted to pad the statistics and attack the 2nd Amendment doesn't give me much hope.
The fact that they piggybacked on a Bush operation as a cover, you can guarantee this is a Clinton operation.
Waco was part of the cover up of a guns for dope operation the Clinton's were involved in and I'm willing to bet that is exactly what F&F is about.
I'm also willing to bet there is a CIA operation to arm the muslims for the “Arab Spring” BS.
Sandy Berger stole highly classified documents, was fined $50,000, and sentenced to two years probation and 100 hours of community service. He too was protecting "his" president. Consequences of governmental criminal behavior are not severe if the executive branch will cover your back.
Elijah Cummings. How did this guy get elected to congress much less become head of a committee? Maybe he’s smarter than the guy he plays on tv, but it takes him 30 seconds to put two words together.
omg, scooby. I am so ignorant. I did not know that. Holder has been a part of destruction of our country for maybe 20 years, and the guy hasn’t been caught yet.
Maybe it will happen today.
How can he live with himself?
,,,,, cool beans !!! ,,, My wife’s B-Day is the 25th of March which also happens to be Maryland Day .
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.