Hasn’t the Supreme Court already ruled in some case that lying, despicable as it might be, is still part of the “freedom of speech” thingy?
That is so 18th century.
Some federal courts have ruled the Stolen Valor Act unconstitutional on First Amendment grounds. The Supreme Court recently said it would take that issue. If it's argued this term, there should be a decision next Spring.
Historically it has not been illegal to lie. Civil damages for lying can only be awarded if the recipient relies on the lie to his financial detriment and his reliance was justified. Criminal penalties for lying generally only apply in cases of fraud with proof of intent to defraud.
What the Justice Department is proposing is just wrong.
Nice catch!
I like the idea that anyone with a law degree who lies any where at any time is guilty of perjury.