My 'problem' is that YOU have gotten conflicting reports from others.
Yet, using some criteria that is not explained; you have chosen one of the reports to be more valid than the other.
My suggestion was that you find out for yourself and NOT listen to others.
If you do not want to; it's no problem to me.
I'll just consider that YOUR opinion of the show is not valid, since you've not seen it and only relied on hearsay to judge it.
Dear, I’m a theatre professional. If you tell me your profession, I promise not to give you advice on how to run your career. So please don’t give me advice on what Broadway shows to see and not to see.
Now this is a silly waste of your time and my time that can be better spent elsewhere.