I say follow the Constitution. 4th and 5th apply.
And, if you read my sources, the Supreme Court disagrees with you. You seem to champion chaos, and chaos never leads you to order. The police are charged to promote Law and Order, not Law and Chaos.
If you don’t like the law, work to overturn it. I like this law, as it can be used to champion the cause of “good”. Here illegally? Wanted on a prior conviction? Bail jumper?
Don’t like it? Then I’d suggest you stay away from the states that have these laws on the books. But, this power does, and should, reside with the state.