[Eleutheria5]

If they do not provide proof, can we assume that he's dead and bomb every Hamas office in the world? Huh? Huh? Can we?

[Yo-Yo]

[TurkeyLurkey]

Wonders never cease...

[Army Air Corps]

Frankly, I think that Shalit has been dead for quite some time and Hamas encourages a degree of doubt on the matter just because they are arseholes.

[camerongood210]

Hamas has already rejected the call, saying that the Red Cross should not intervene in Israel's "security games."

Anthony Weiner must be an adviser for Hamas.

[proud American in Canada]

For a moment, I thought this was about Gene Shalit, the movie critic.

[Cheburashka]

If they do not provide proof, can we assume that he's dead and bomb every Hamas office in the world? Huh? Huh? Can we?

---

Why so you need any other reason than it exists to attack any Hamas office anywhere? Feel free.

Sadly, Shalit is probably dead. A prisoner you have to feed and keep under guard, and there is always a risk that he might escape or that the location he is being held will be discovered and a commando mission will free him - how embarrassing to Hamas if either were to happen. Dead prisoners you just bury in a shallow grave. Since Israel has demonstrated that they will exchange live prisoners for the dead there is no downside as an asset in negotiations - you just dig him up when you do the exchange.

[Ratman83]

Lets just bomb with or without proof, it is what they do.