Replies

The only thing you saw was Cain framing. He used the technique of framing to give him some time to give his answer which was:

WALLACE: Question: what would President Cain offer the Palestinians to make peace?

CAIN: Nothing. Because I'm not convinced that the Palestinians are really interested in peace. If the Palestinians come to the table with Israel, with a genuine offer that the two of them can sit down and negotiate, the United States would, in fact, try to facilitate that discussion.

But if we look at history, it has been clear that the Palestinians have always wanted to push Israelis and push Israel for more and more and more. I don't agree with that. I respect Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu for taking a stand and saying they cannot give that up.

Secondly, it's Israel's decision, not President Obama's decision to where the borderlines ought to be.

WALLACE: Where do you stand on the right of return?

CAIN: The right of return? The right of return?

WALLACE: The Palestinian right of return.

CAIN: That is something that should be negotiated. That is something that should be negotiated.

WALLACE: Do you think the Palestinian refugees, the people who were kicked out of the land in 1948, should be able or should have any right to return to Israeli land?

CAIN: Yes. But under -- but not under Palestinian conditions. Yes. They should have a right to come back if that is a decision that Israel wants to make.

Back to -- it's up to Israel to determine the things they will accept. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made it real clear in his statement following the statement that President Obama made. They are wiling to make some concessions. They are willing to give on a lot of things. They are willing to be compassionate.

I don't think they have a big problem with people returning. The issue is there are some things that they simply do not want to give in on.

How you could have read it, much less heard it another way is unbelievable.

Cain gave the right and appropriate answer.

Rather than being disturbed that he did not have an answer on the right of return issue, I am rather more concerned that he did not pick up on the statement, “the Palestinian refugees, the people who were kicked out of the land in 1948.” He should certainly have asked for clarification as to who was responsible for “kicking them out”. I suspect that Wallace was referring to Jews. I have known for 40 years that it was Arabs who forced the Palestinians to abandon their homes when the war broke out. Apparently Cain is not aware of this important aspect either.