[trumandogz]

“This guy should have recused himself. Especially since he decided in the manner that he did.”

Should Thurgood Marshall or Justice Thomas recused theirself from cases that had to do with civil rights or Affrimitive Action?

Should Sandra Day O’Conner recused herself from cases that had to do with women?

Should the current Catholic Justices recuse themselves from cases dealing with abortion?

[Guenevere]

Not the same!....and you know it

[IrishCatholic]

Really? Is that your level of reasoning? Moral equivalency?

[IrishCatholic]

http://www.scribd.com/doc/35374462/California-Prop-8-Ruling-August-2010

The findiings of fact should put this strawman to rest. Try Fact 77, it is one of my favorites.

[El Cid]

“This guy should have recused himself. Especially since he decided in the manner that he did.”
Should Thurgood Marshall or Justice Thomas recused theirself from cases that had to do with civil rights or Affrimitive Action?
Should Sandra Day O’Conner recused herself from cases that had to do with women?
Should the current Catholic Justices recuse themselves from cases dealing with abortion?

Quite the strawmen you lined up there.

The analogy you were searching for was:

"Should a Judge addicted to a particular perversion recuse himself from a case involving his perversion?"

[Grizzled Bear]

Well hi there, troomie!

It’s just so super to see you!

How have you been you sweety pants!

[freedomwarrior998]

Laughable attempt at equivocation, and an epic failure. Walker demonstrated that he had both a personal stake in the outcome of the case (automatic disqualifier) and an unbelievable bias during the entire proceeding, to the point that he disregarded both settled precedent (Baker v. Nelson) and procedural rules.

[Doc91678]

Since when does a self selected life style equate with one’s sexual assignment, or color?