For all of Hamilton’s genius (and he was the genius of the founding fathers) he never believed that a corrupt Democrat party led by Jefferson, Madison and Burr would be able to rule in spite of the Constitution. No one was more into realpolitik than he but he was a rank idealist when it came to the forces he faced within this nation.
When you’ve lived all your life in a society based on Christian values, it would be hard to fathom a dominant humanist/satanic society and people of that worldview attaining office.