Posted on 03/22/2011 6:52:11 PM PDT by Dallas59
ORLANDO, Florida (Reuters) – Some public school parents in Edgewater, Florida, want a first-grade girl with life-threatening peanut allergies removed from the classroom and home-schooled, rather than deal with special rules to protect her health, a school official said.
"That was one of the suggestions that kept coming forward from parents, to have her home-schooled. But we're required by federal law to provide accommodations. That's just not even an option for us," said Nancy Wait, spokeswoman for the Volusia County School District.
Wait said the 6-year-old's peanut allergy is so severe it is considered a disability under the Americans with Disabilities Act.
(Excerpt) Read more at news.yahoo.com ...
Anecdotal I know but my 100% breast fed son has a peanut allergy.
And I think it’s silly to punish everyone else for his problem. He simply avoids peanuts. If it was so bad he couldn’t even be near peanuts we would have removed him from the environment rather than ask the majority to accommodate his individual needs. That’s just selfish!
So do I but I could not get Sassy’s daddy to agree. When she got hit in the mouth with the hockey stick he flipped out on the school. I am still in shock he wasn’t arrested. They lied to us about it & said it was no big deal she was bleeding etc. We felt differently of course & well I let him deal with it lol.
Interesting ping.
No need to show off your allergies to me. All these exotic allergies did not exist when I was little. They exist today because we are giving birth to weaker specimens plus people find ways to weaken themselves enough to develop allergies. Allergies don’t mean you are special they mean you are weak. I am firm on this and won’t be responding
I hold the list, or JenB if I’m on vacation or out fo town for some reason.
The parents should homeschool her. They’d be doing her a favor to begin with. And they wouldn’t be holding the whole world hostage.
I sent my daughter with homemade honey sweetened wholewheat banana bread with unsalted butter on it and they called me saying students were not allowed to bring cake with frosting for snack. I explained what I had sent and their response was well it looked like cake to us. sigh
Private school, public school I dealt with them both, home school was definitely best!
I wonder about that too. How many more years to we have to wait to unseal records from Carter's presidency... in particular any records having to do with deals between the government and peanut farmers. Maybe they did something to try and stimulate people's taste for peanuts and this is a side-effect.
I am on the list, but couldn’t remember who pinged it. Late night. Thanks for the reply.
The problem with peanut allergies is that they can be so life threatening that even contact with peanut residue can cause an anaphylactic reaction.
With gluten sensitivities, you have to eat the food to have the problem. Skin contact doesn’t cause a reaction, as peanuts can.
Peanuts are one of the WORST allergens out there.
There are a lot of overblown conditions, but considering how fast a severe reaction can occur, this girl’s life could literally be in danger. Her airway could swell shut in seconds.
And think of this.....
She and her family would be depending on the public school to initially treat her should she have a reaction, until professional help can be had.
That is down right scary. But I had to deal with that foolish nurse who fought with me over the inhaler. I got so mad that Sassy couldn't keep her inhaler at her desk I had my lawyer ( her Godfather) write a letter to the BOE threatening a lawsuit. She was able to have her inhaler. If she had to wait for that nurse to waddle down to the classroom with the inhaler she could have died.
Yes, there are clinical trials being run at various medical centers in the country. IIRC, Mt. Sinai in NYC is one of them.
Apparently, they have been reasonably successful. Not all cases all the time, but it is something the parents should be checking out.
In the meantime, do the kid a favor and homeschool her.
There are other factors which can worsen an allergic condition.
Stress is one of the big ones. Anyone with allergies can tell you that when they are under stress of any kind, mental, emotional, physical, it can and will worsen symptoms.
Probably because people aren’t dying from it any more and are living to pass the sensitivity along.
I know a child like this. He IS homeschooled, because the classroom simply can’t be made adequately safe for his allergies.
He has a peanut sniffing dog. Before he sits at a table in our center, the dog comes over and sniffs the table. The other day someone set their sandwich wrapper on the table, and the mother went and cleaned the table under where the rapper was (it was not a peanut butter sandwich).
The problem is, the class can’t be made safe for him, if he is that allergic. Other kids are going to eat peanuts, and he will be exposed.
The latest theory on why allergies are on the rise is the connection to the hypercleanliness of our environment.
Hygiene hypothesis
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hygiene_hypothesis
Basically, early exposure (under a year old even) to harmless bacteria in our environment trains the child’s immune system to react properly to invading antigens, instead of the hypersensitivity reaction of allergies.
Studies have found that the youngest child in a family has fewer allergies than older siblings. Children living in the country have fewer allergies than city dwellers, with dairy farm kids having the least.
Another observation is that continual exposure is necessary to keep allergies at bay. College age kids who go off to college, come back to find that they are now allergic to the family cat, which never bothered them before. I have friends who developed allergies later in life after moving off the family farm.
Many people think that anti-biotics play a role in triggering allergies. Whether they do or not, all I know is that my youngest, who was virtually never on them at all, has virtually no allergies, while my older two have allergies in proportion to the amount of anti-biotics they took as babies.
There’s an excellent article in an old edition of Science News, from about 1999 IIRC, called *Germs of Endearment*. It was the cover article but Science News has changed their website and I can’t find it now in their archives.
The reason group discipline doesn't work is because it gives the trouble maker power over the other kids.
He's going to get in trouble anyway, but it's far more rewarding when he can ruin it for other kids who have done no wrong. That's its own reward for the bully and he will do it, just to make the other kids mad and know that they can't retaliate.
Group punishment is just wrong on so many levels.
The only time I could see justifying it is when a group is protecting the troublemaker.
What are these parents NUTS! ( Pardon the deliberate pun.) They are placing their daughter's **life** in the hands of a classroom of 6 year olds, a busy teacher, and who know how many caretakers outside the school? Unbelievable!
Sure they existed when we were kids. People tended to die from them first, though. Peanut allergies are no exotic. They are very common with peanuts being one of the worst allergens.
And no, allergies do not mean you are weak. On the contrary, the immune system is doing too good a job.
If you don't plan on responding, why'd you come on the thread just to poke a stick in other's eye?
BTW, we get it. You think you're pretty speshul.....
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.