Posted on 11/19/2010 6:50:35 AM PST by WebFocus
By telling Barbara Walters that she thinks she can defeat President Obama, Sarah Palin has dimmed hopes cherished by sensible Republicans that she might decide against a run for the White House in 2012. Here are just some of the reasons she should not run.
The Republican nominee should be someone with a vast and impressive record in government and the private sector. Voters chose a novice with plenty of star power in 2008 and will be inclined to swing strongly in the other direction in 2012. Americans will be looking for sober competence, managerial skill, and maturity not sizzle and flash.
After the 2008 campaign revealed her substantive weaknesses, Palin was advised by those who admired her natural gifts to bone up on policy and devote herself to governing Alaska successfully. Instead, she quit her job as governor after two and a half years, published a book (another is due next week), and seemed to chase money and empty celebrity. Now, rather than being able to highlight the accomplishments of Sarah Palins Alaska, we get Sarah Palins Alaska, another cheesy entrant in the reality-show genre. Shed so much rather be out dog sledding than in some dull political office, she tells the audience. File that.
Its true. She is wildly popular with a swath of the Republican electorate. And, as a conservative woman politician told me, political consultants (who get paid the big bucks, win or lose) will doubtless descend upon her with game plans showing how she can win in Iowa and then cruise to the nomination. Maybe. But the general election would be a problem, since 53 percent of independent voters view Palin unfavorably along with 81 percent of Democrats, according to a recent Gallup poll.
There is no denying that Sarah Palin has been harshly, sometimes even brutally, treated by the press and the entertainment gaggle. But any prominent Republican must expect and be able to transcend that. Palin compares herself to Reagan. But Reagan didnt mud-wrestle with the press. Palin seems consumed and obsessed by it, as her rapid Twitter finger attests, and thus she encourages the sniping. She should be presiding over meetings on oil and gas leases in the North Slope, or devising alternatives to Obamacare. Every public spat with Dave Letterman or Politico, or the lamestream media, or (God help us) Levi Johnston, diminishes her.
Speaking of television, have you watched Dancing with the Stars? Calling the show cheesy would be too generous. Perhaps the former governor should not be blamed for the decisions of her adult daughter. Yet there in the audience we see Sarah and Todd Palin, mugging for the camera and cheering on their unwed-mother daughter as she bumps and grinds to the tune of Mamma Told Me Not To Come. Her parents had advised her, the 20-year-old Bristol told an interviewer, that she had to stay in character if she expected to win. Being in character evidently meant descending to the vulgarity that DWTS peddles on a weekly basis. The mama grizzly was apparently unfazed by, or equally disturbingly unaware of, the indignity. And she is supposed to be a conservative culture warrior?
Voters prize judgment, above all, in a presidential candidate. Some of Sarah Palins 2010 endorsements were sound and arguably helpful. Others betrayed flightiness and recklessness. Tom Tancredo, Palins choice for governor of Colorado, has ridden his anti-immigration hobby-horse in a style perfectly suited to alienate Hispanic voters (describing Miami, for example, as a Third World city). Her endorsement of Christine ODonnell was irresponsible and damaging, losing a seat that would otherwise have been a Republican pick-up. Of course, ODonnell received an absurdly disproportionate amount of ink and attention during the race (the liberal press naturally seizes upon any opportunity to make conservatives look kooky), but Palin should have anticipated that. Besides, this one cannot be laid at the feet of the biased media. ODonnell was a thoroughly unqualified candidate.
Palin has many strengths. I admire her fortitude and her principles. Her ability to connect with a crowd is something most politicians can only dream of. I will always remember her 2008 convention speech as a rollicking star turn. She would be terrific as a talk-show host the new Oprah.
But a presidential candidate? Someone to convince critical independent voters that Republicans can govern successfully? Absolutely not.
Mona Charen is a nationally syndicated columnist.
I guess you should go back to DU or Myth's campaign office and tell them that you failed again.
This is true. But unfortunately anyone who doesn’t worship the ground Palin walks on is a RINO, CINO, Romney supporter, etc. We’re just going through the cult of celebrity with Obama. Don’t need to do it again in 2 years with Palin.
That's funny. You haven't been paying any attention. SOme PDSers are even trying to kneecap DeMint.
oops. :)
Thank you, Jim!
Palin Demint 2012
Palin Pence 2012
Keep in mind NR didn’t endorse Romney because they thought he was the best conservative candidate. They endorsed him because they thought he was the best of the lot running who actually had a shot at winning a national campaign.
It only takes one more ...
For all those supporting a Palin 2012 bid, I’d love to know how they think she will win a national election. Where is the evidence that she can convince anyone outside of her die hard fans to vote for her? I have friends and family who are very conservative (listen to Rush every day, watch Fox News at night) and they’ve told me more than once if she’s the nominee they will stay home and not vote.
Fail?
My concern is that some have pre-ordained the former AK gov as the “only hope” for the GOP in 2012 to beat Obama.
Tell me what about Palin has you so “weak in the knees?”
Her record sucks, she has QUIT two of the three govt jobs she has held, one after just a year & the other after 2 1/2 year. And you what she in the WH?
If she can’t handle being gov of AK for 4 years, why would you want to give her the keys to the WH?
“You lie.”
Your friends aren’t real conservatives, they’re Repubs.
Ain't it the truth. Lots of trolls and concern trolls. Jim has been busy.
He shoots; He scores!!!!! (?)
What a noob you are....she didn’t quit...she took a promotion.
Your concern is recognized.
Nobody has taken on Obama like Palin has...nobody has worked harder than Palin has at being the loyal opposition.
She deserves the nomination and she will get it.
Like your list, but I’d throw out Gingrich (too much baggage) and add Ryan (yes I know he says he’s not interested).
Liberals, This Is Proof That Sarah Palin Has Executive Experience: I Present Her Record
She quit. That's the inescapable fact.
When are they going to ban you? It’s really tiresome having to notice your little steaming piles aka “comments”.
One of three commissioners of the Alaska Oil and Gas Conservation Commission, a state level position that she QUIT and later was named a co-director of the “Ted Stevens Excellence in Public Service, Inc” a private 527 corp, that was some promotion.
Gov of AK to VPOTUS, sorry, I forgot, she lost and then QUIT.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.