Letting both “winners” vote is somewhat like Solomon giving half the baby to each of the “winning” moms. Furthermore, it changes the vote stealing to one of trying to make sure you wind up within that magic 1 or 2% trigger.
Think about it just a tiny bit, even if the dems were to steal their way into such a tie here and there, far less damage would have been done and would only consist of a 53% majority losing its ability to disenfranchise the other 47% or something like that.
As I see it, we need to either get this stuff straight somehow or other or split the country up. The system at present is barely working.