You are right to demand proof when dealing with brithers.
They very often just make things up. Alternatively, they will hear a something that someone else just made up, credulously accept its truth, and continue to repeat it over and over again as if it were a fact, when it's not.
Here are some examples of made up "facts" that birthers here continue to repeat uncritically: 1)that Obama's Indonesian-born half sister has a Hawaiian COLB 2)that McCain made a copy of his birth certificate available to the public 3) that the Senate held hearings on McCain's eligibility, and that he submitted a copy of his BC into evidence 4) that there was a US travel ban on Pakistan when Obama traveled there 5) that Obama and his half sister at one point stated he was born in Queens hospital 6)that Obama's grandmother said he was born in Kenya 7) that other members of his family say he was born in Kenya.
None of the above claims has ever been substiantiated. Some of them have been disproven. Nevertheless, you will see birthers repeating them again and again as if they were facts.
And that's just a sampling. There are many more examples where those came from.
A more recent example: Ron Pollard (a.k.a. Polarik) photoshopped an image of a COLB proporting to be Obama's that has many discrepancies from the one Obama released in 2008. Some birthers took Polarik's word for it that this new COLB was genuine, and began citing the discrepancies as "proof" that the original one Obama released was forged. Polarik later admitted that the new COLB wasn't real, but some birthers continue to cite it as if it were real.
In short, don't believe anything a birther says unless he provides documentation.
Curiosity: the astrophysicists at MIT and CalTech want to talk with you. They've never seen a black hole in a skull before.
Besides muffing my name - it's POLLAND - you were totally in another reality when you claimed that I "began citing the discrepancies [in the Rev. 10/08 COLB] as "proof" that the original one Obama released was forged.
At least, you're consistent in your nonsense. Did not get the content of this post, or any post of mine, anywhere in the ballpark in the past two years. Stee-r-rike, three hundred! You're outta here!
Hand in your torch and leave this island immediately.
double ditto for the anti-birthers; so far, the reality painted by the Obama/DNC/HIDH omissions has a stronger foothold.
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"