We might have an argument if you had actually read, and actually responded, to my post.
Those who do not attend mass weekly are not Catholics, however they may self identify to exit pollsters. Among those Catholics who actually are Catholics -- that is, fulfill their weekly obligation -- McCain won by nine points.
More to the point, the people being maligned on this forum as being no better than the US Catholic Episcopate are solid conservatives and fellow FReepers. They take the Apostles' Creed every week, and they take it seriously, so baiting them on this forum -- or any conservative venue -- is stupid.
You want to talk about peripheral issues, fine. New Immigrants voted for big government; nothing surprising or new. Roosevelt fooled a lot of people -- including by his own admission my Dad, who was young and foolish at the time.
Here are four reliable Catholic votes: Scalia, Thomas, Roberts and Alito. Know your FRiends.
Sorry but those people that you deny, are Catholics, you try to thread so many needles, that it is clear you just want to sell an agenda, your efforts are what people on the street call a con man’s rap.