They can do that as individual States -- by leaving the present Union and forming their own.
If they wish to do so collectively, acting as a Union, to expel a member from the existing Compact, their Compact of Union must specify that they can do that -- because the Union only has such Powers as are specifically ceded to it by the individual States.
We're talking about the Constitution here, not some club. You've been talking about freedom of association and church membership and all the rest. Well then what part of the Constitution prevents the states from exercising their right of free association and booting a state out of the Union. It's still a simple question. Why not answer it?
Answered above.
No, it's more a question about your asinine "unilateral secession" ideology. You say that a state can walk out, at will, without permission, because the Constitution does not prevent it. Well then by extension a state can be kicked out, at will, without its permission, because nothing in the Constitution prevents that. Right? If not then what clause of the Constitution prevents it? And I doubt that the Constitution works the way you seem to want it to as well.
Unilateral Secession is how this Nation was founded.
I'm arguing for the 1776 rights of the States to secede from the British Union.
You're arguing for the 1776 right of the British Union to compel them to stay.
IOW, your position is directly opposed to the Founding Ideals of America.
That is not what I am asking. Can a state be expelled against its will by the other states? Yes or no? If not, what clause of the Constitution prevents it?
If they wish to do so collectively, acting as a Union, to expel a member from the existing Compact, their Compact of Union must specify that they can do that -- because the Union only has such Powers as are specifically ceded to it by the individual States.
Let me quote the 10th Amendment to you: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people." So what part of the Constitution prohibits the states from expelling another state against their will?
Answered above.
No, you haven't. In order to answer the question you need to tell me what clause in the Constitution prevents it.
Unilateral Secession is how this Nation was founded.
This nation was founded by starting and winning a rebellion against the British government. The Revolutionary War? 1776-1783? Perhaps you've heard of it?
I'm arguing for the 1776 rights of the States to secede from the British Union. You're arguing for the 1776 right of the British Union to compel them to stay.
OK, just so I'm clear here. What you are saying is that under British law the colonists had the legal right to peacefully leave the empire, to secede? And that King George was in the wrong for trying to prevent it? Is that what you want us to believe? Can you point to something that supports this?
IOW, your position is directly opposed to the Founding Ideals of America.
I honestly don't understand your position at all. You seem to be all over the board.