Posted on 09/11/2009 9:09:57 AM PDT by NCjim
Joe Wilson wasn't the only Republican who was fed up with Obama's dishonest, partisan speech Wednesday. Rep. John Shimkus walked out on Obama's speech, as reported by Mark Silva of the Chicago Tribune's Washington Bureau Swamp blog.
"Congressman Shimkus was frustrated that the president was not offering any new ground and left with just minutes remaining in the speech,'' spokesman Steven Tomaszewski said today.
Many conservatives love this sort of acting out, because they have the same impulse. Joe Wilson, while condemned by the Dems and their media lapdogs, is a hero to many activists. Others, like AT's Ethel C. Fenig, decry incivility and see it handing ammunition to our enemies.
Once again, Republicans are being decried as uncivil and worse. But it turns out that the real story is a bit more complex. The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, in a roundup of reactions, credits Dana Milbank:
"And, in truth, there were provocations from the Democratic side," he wrote. "Rep. Bill Pascrell, D-N.J., sitting on the Republican side, insisted on making a victory sign with his hand and waving it at Obama. Rep. Al Green, D-Texas, also on the GOP side of the aisle, felt the need to pound his fist in the air and make what looked, awkwardly, like a fascist salute."
I am not so certain that this acting out is such a bad thing. I remember conservative pundits from Charles Krauthammer on down lecturing us that the town hall demonstrations were going to backfire and turn public opinion in Obama's favor. They were dead wrong then.
The American people are not quite as prissy as the conservative elites, for whom polish and politeness are ideals. The media-generated stereotype of Neanderthal conservatives has made it essential for those conservatives who wishe to be taken seriously in American elite circles to be on their best behavior constantly, and to deplore anything which reinforces the Neanderthal meme.
The hypocrisy of the left is breathtaking here. We recently experienced 8 years of dissent as the highest expression of patriotism, and hissing of POTUS during a State of the Union address. The widespread snickering when a shoe was thrown at George Bush demonstrates the phoniness of much of this outrage. These memories have not completely faded. The connection between the words liberal and hypocrite gets one more reinforcement.
The implicit symbolic message of extraordinary actions is that we are in extraordinary times. The reason the left turned to demonstrations as a mainstay tactic in the civil rights and Vietnam War campaigns is because they work. They draw attention, and can cause people to think. With abundant attention from a sympathetic media, they were able to put their causes on the national agenda. They were afforded opportunities to make their case.
The public is already skeptical about Obama's health care sales job, and by seeing that some just can't stomach what Obama is saying, they know something extraordinary is going on. The dominant media will not support them, of course, but those media are trusted by a diminishing minority of Americans, most of them somewhere on the left hand side of the spectrum. Among the undecideds, media huffing and puffing about conservatives is not enough to discredit a cause anymore. The public reaction to town hall protests showed that. Alternative media have gained enough traction that we can exploit the lacunae in the MSM coverage and gain the public's attention.
Slowly, slowly, people in the middle are awakening to the fact that Obama is no ordinary president, but rather one who has an agenda on which he did not premise his candidacy. The media may yawn as the system-altering changes are implemented one after another, changes that will weaken and impoverish America for generations. That is an awful thought to contemplate, and people avoid thinking it. But when they see that thought expressed by others, and see other disquieting signs that things are not quite normal with this guy in the White House, they may entertain the possibility.
Tomorrow, an unknown number of people will greet the Tea Party Express in Washington, DC. in the 9/12 demonstration. Another sign to the American public that these are not normal times. The usual suspects will huff and puff, if they cover the event at all. A lot of good it will do them! The public will make up its own mind, as it continues to think through this health care issue, and refine their understanding of this still unknown president, in only his third year of national prominence.
Most people care deeply about their health care. They aren't going to be rushed into ObamaCare, and enough Dems in Congress know that they could lose their seats if the public turns against it.
Disclaimer: I do not advocate rude behavior by anyone. I personally believe in self-restrain and civility. And that Neanderthal thing has been a stone around my neck in left-dominated academic and cultural settings.
But a movement without passion is an idle preoccupation, not a political force. Let's not actively encourage this sort of thing. But keep in mind that a battle is being waged and that the left has showed us the complex way symbolic acts can affect the public consciousness when a movement is building.
Republicans should have walked out.
They should lose their seats anyway. They're a bunch of crooks. Out!
I agree, but that requires guts.
There is a difference between bad form and true evil.
They did not expect the conservatives to come out so forcefully on '00.
Of course you are right, but this bunch of “Republicans” are a bunch of appeasing cowards.
Mrs. Palin has more stones than the lot of them.
It’s not like we are biting off people’s fingers.
The mealy mouthed Republicans are letting the Republicans, conservatives and in truth the American people down very badly.
The complaint we have a plan too ..., and can not get it out, is weak at best ...
There are some media that would get it out, if they truly came forth and explained in particulars, what the Republican plan is.
If nothing else some conservative businesses would underwrite the expense. True Conservatives will pay to get the message out to the people ... IF a plan exists. MO
Agreed. But so should the Democrats who got a new one reamed out by their electorate during town hall meetings.
Etxactly. I kept hoping—especially since the signs so many GOPers were holding could have communicated a mass exodus. But Patrick Henry didn’t walk out, and I often wonder whether he was officially recognized before he spoke.
As much as I like this idea at face value it would set a really bad precedent.
Conservative Patriots should have walked out......I could care less what 'republicans" do.
obama lied about rationing for seniors, illegal immigrants, and the effect of his bogus proposal on the deficit, among other things. At the same time, he accused the Townhall protesters, Sarah Palin, etc. of lying. Who’s the uncivil one?
obama “care” is NOT about health care, but about national surveillance (i.e., those “electronic records”), demographic engineering, and moving toward dictatorship. Congress members and Senators who support it should lose their seats, whether the wretched proposal passes or not!!!!
According to some reports one did.
The moment O accused Republicans of lying the meeting ought to have been over.
No, not bad enough. Why should we be be considerate of evil and those who wish to destroy us?
Peaceful protest only works when your opponent has more integrity than you yourself do otherwise you have Tienanmen square rather than Gandhi.
We are suffering the death of 1000 courtesy's.
Speak truth to action.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.