Posted on 09/07/2009 9:38:34 AM PDT by nickcarraway
Mississippian's challenge to opponents to burn their cards called 'very cynical'/B>
Oppose a government health care plan? A Jackson, Miss., doctor wants you to put your convictions on the line by burning your mother's Medicare card.
It's the reverse of the challenge many citizens have been issuing to their own members of Congress to forgo the health care plans they get by dint of working for the government and buy into the "public option" plan instead.
"I want to have a demonstration - Boston Tea Party-like - and burn those cards," said Dr. Aaron Shirley, who has done extensive work in trying to extend health care to the uninsured.
His challenge is just one of the ones that's been made to lawmakers as they fanned out across the country this summer to make the case for or against a government overhaul of health care. Skeptical voters repeatedly demanded that their members of Congress live by the principles they espouse.
For Democrats who support President Obama's plan to have the government sponsor a "public option" health insurance plan, voters demanded that the lawmakers themselves buy into that government plan.
That challenge by-and-large has been deflected by lawmakers, who say they choose from among a number of plans and say the key is to give options to everyone.
"This is about choice, you understand? It's not about mandating a choice for anybody," Rep. Bennie Thompson, Mississippi Democrat, told a woman who challenged him last week to buy into the public option plan at a town-hall meeting in Jackson.
"I choose your plan," the woman said, to which Mr. Thompson replied, "Well, that's fine - run for Congress.
(Excerpt) Read more at washingtontimes.com ...
Then we don’t have to pay into Medicare right???
Half the wealth in America is owned by those over 65. Medicare is just another handout to the wealthy under the guise of politically correct ‘caring’.
I will burn my s.s. card and my medicare if they refund my money with interest.
You phoney unethical smirk-faced a-holes never want to face the real deal--that we didn't sign up for this voluntarily, we didn't have the choice in the first place.
But since we've already been forced to pay for it, heck yes we'll take it.
“Then we don’t have to pay into Medicare right???”
Starve the beast!! Tax avoidance is legal!
Medicare is a handout?
Who paid into Medicare?
Who pays $96 per month for Medicare once they reach 65?
Half the wealth is owned by those over 65?
So Gates, Forbes, Kennedy, and the tech company owners are all over 65?
FINE BY ME!!!!!
Give me back all my FORCED medicare taxes (with interest) and we will CALL IT EVEN.
I will take the SAME DEAL with social security.
No problem, give me my money back at 5% compunded and I’ll forgo Social Security, Medicare and the can keep the flag from my future demise as well.
Second, Medicare is bankrupting hospitals and care givers, and contributing significantly to the costs of private insurance. Medicare pays only a fraction of the real costs of care, and hospitals try to recoup the loses somewhat by shifting costs to those with private insurance.
Here's a nice example from a thread here earlier..
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/2332980/posts?page=3
Even more, get a refund of all the money they payed in. I think most people would burn their cards if that was the deal.
Clever retort. Too clever by half. By saying that, Thompson acknowledges that it's perfectly acceptable for differences to exist in health plans. Totally undercuts his position that everyone must have the same coverage. Well, everyone who is not him and the rest of Congress.
OK, then pay me back all the money you took from my paychecks as Medicare deductions, with appropriate interest, and I’ll take care of my own healthcare.
I would opt out of the Medicare system today if—
1) all my Medicare taxes were returned plus interest compounded at the T-bill rate
2) I could spend the money, pre-tax, on my own healthcare; or I could use the money anyway way I want after-tax
This is a choice we will never get. After the Democrats get through with health-care, our choices will be very-limited (the law will define what must be in your coverage, the government will run even private insurance by proxy). There is a story that a customer asked Henry Ford for a choice in car color, Ford responded, “You can have any color you want as long as it is black or tan.”
Burn my mother’s medicare card? Here’s a radical thought: How about we let my mother decide for herself? That would be true choice, the exact element missing from HR3200, and any other version of liberal government-decided health care.
This Dr. Shirley sounds like another Black Marxist Rev Wright. I’ll bet this Dr. Shirley is running some scams of his own in the name of ‘free’ healthcare to the po’....time for a little investigation on this tool!
I'll do the same as long as the payment is in inflation-adjusted dollars or an equal value in gold! We'll both be rich!
People on Medicare have worked and paid into the system for years to be eligible for it. They also pay a monthly premium. Medicare isn’t required to draw Social Security, but if they have it the premium is automatically deducted from their monthly check. This moron should lead the way by burning his medical license. It would make as much sense.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.