Posted on 06/26/2009 9:37:13 PM PDT by sickoflibs
The entire presumption of the Obama-proposed Consumer Financial Protection Agency is that banks and mortgage companies are under-regulated by the state. This is why the financial meltdown took place — never mind that the federal regulatory Gosplan includes tens of thousands of pages purporting to regulate the mortgage industry alone.
Let's leave aside the unknown costs that will be associated with new regulations — ever more hoops to jump through, more paperwork, more confusing terms for lenders and borrowers alike, more government controls that harm consumers as much as or more than producers. The core problem here is that none of this rigmarole has anything to do with the real reason for the meltdown.
The role that legislation plays in sending signals to real-world market participants is tiny by comparison to the role of market prices, among which are the interest rate. Here is the signal that is organic to the market economy, generated by the choices and values of all the people in society.
Prices are the market's intrinsic method for allocating resources according to the priorities of individuals. These prices include the exchange ratios for final products and prices all up and down the structure of production. They also include wages, the market signal that regulates relations between workers and employers.
But for the investment sector, the critical price signal is the interest rate. It is this which rewards and punishes investment decisions. It conveys information about the capacity of consumers to purchase in the future. A high interest rate indicates a lack of saving and a shift toward more present-oriented economic decisions. Conversely, a low interest rate tells lenders and borrowers that there is plenty of spare saving to go around.
In the early 2000s, the Federal Reserve manipulated the interest rate in a downward direction, one which was not justified by market realities. This action misled consumers and producers to undertake investments that were unsustainable. In particular, financial energy poured into the housing market, a sector which had been a political priority for successive presidential administrations.
To understand the implications, imagine if a fine restaurant advertised a five-course meal and French wine for all comers — at $1 each. Would the customers be exuberant? You bet. They would be wild with anticipation, choosing to stand in a line and hang out at the restaurant rather than do other things with their time.
The restaurant would be packed and happy, though of course it couldn't sustain this in the long run, but the fun is great while it lasts. At some point, reality kicks in. The manager notes that there are no more tables and maybe no more food. The employees are exhausted. Moreover, the balance sheets don't line up: they are losing money on every meal they serve. At some point, the manager is going to have to announce the bad news and everyone is going to have to go home.
This is roughly what happened with the current boom and bust. Policy makers, however, seem to be under the assumption that they can keep the boom going on forever simply by dropping the interest rate ever lower. This is something like a restaurant owner thinking that he can continue to have people wait in line even though he has no tables or food or servers remaining. It is a physical and economic impossibility for him to make good on his promises.
At some point in this process, people begin to drift away and go on to other things. The manager can continue to advertise $1 meals in the hope of stimulating his business but this is simply illusion. No one is buying it; even if they did, the restaurant can't make the balance sheets work out. We can venture a prediction here that this restaurant will not be stimulated. It will enter into a prolonged period of inactivity until nothing is left.
This is precisely what the Obama administration is attempting to do. So you can see that regulations in this climate mean absolutely nothing. You can pass a regulation that says, "All customers must continue to wait in line," or that "all meals that have been promised must be delivered," or that "restaurants must keep stores of food and wine on hand for high-traffic days," but none of them really apply because the core problem has deeper roots. The regulations are even destructive, because they end up applying to everyone alike: the good restaurants that are telling the truth and the bad ones that continue to mislead people.
Even the establishment of a Restaurant Customer Protection Agency is not going to fix up this situation, which is already hopeless. Creating an agency like this only ends up mucking up a system that is otherwise self-correcting.
The Bush administration began the ridiculous economic boom as a way of preventing a recession that was underway already at the time of the 2001 terrorist attacks. Creating funny money via low interest rates was the Bush way of fighting back against the terrorists. Very stupid, because look where it got us. We have experienced the worst financial panic on record, which has devastated us economically far more than the terror attacks.
This is why Obama's fix-it plans are based on a denial of reality. The downturn might eventually end, but with ever more regulations imposed on the system, we might find ourselves never again living in a vibrant and prosperous society.
If you realize both parties in Washington think our money is theirs and you trust them to do the wrong thing, this list is for you.
If you think there is a Santa Claus who is going to get elected in Washington and cut a few taxes and spend a few trillion and jump start the economy, and get our lost money back, this list is not for you.
You can read past posts by clicking on : schifflist , I try to tag all relevant threads with the keyword : schifflist.
Ping list pinged by sickoflibs.
To join the ping list: FReepmail sickoflibs with the subject line add Schifflist.
(Stop getting pings by sending the subject line drop Schifflist.)
We sure could use an Out of Control Government Taxpayer Protection agency.
Do I need to call Obama to ask for permission to er, evacuate myself? “#1 or #2”
Why did money flow especially into the housing market?
Good question. What if you rented and saved that money while the fed was making dollars worthless and the buyers got the two tax deductions and all your friends were getting rich with a big house and rentals? My brother in law lost it and pressured my sister into going along with rentals at the peak of the bubble in a high bubble bust area. They are really good people but when everyone is calling you stupid and the CONSERVATIVES, Hannity, Levin, Rush are tell you a bubble economy is real economic growth, how can you not get in ??? I didn't I saw the internet bubble and played it safe but I cant help exposing so called mainstreal Bush-bot conservative defenders .
Subject: OBAMA'S GENIUSES - They Can Fix Anything !!!
David E. Cole, Chairman, Center for Automotive Research (CAR and Professor at the Univ. of Michigan is an engineer by training and tells many stories of the difficulty of working with the folks that the Obama administration has sent to save the auto industry. He relates that there have been many meetings where a 20.. 30 ...40+ year experience automotive experts have to listen to a newcomer to the industry, someone with zero manufacturing experience, zero auto industry experience, zero business experience, zero finance experience, and zero engineering experience, tell them how to run their business.
Mr Cole's favorite story is as follows:
There was a team of Obama people speaking to Mr. Cole (Engineer, automotive experience 40+ years, Chairman of CAR). They were explaining to Mr. Cole that the auto companies needed to make a car that was electric and liquid natural gas (LNG) with enough combined fuel to go 500 miles so we wouldn't "need" so many gas stations (A whole other topic). They were quoting BTU's of LNG and battery life that they had looked up on some website. Mr. Cole explained that to do this you would need a trunk FULL of batteries and a LNG tank as big as a car to make that happen and that there were problems related to the laws of physics that prevented them from....
The Lead Obama person interrupted and said, "These laws of physics; who's rules are those? We need to change that ! " Some of the others wrote down the law name so they could look it up . He continued, " We have the congress and the administration. We can repeal those laws , amend them , or use an executive order to get rid of that problem. That's why we are here, to fix these sort of issues".
I am an engineer and I can tell you, that is Washington DC power, Washington is ‘tell the voters you can give them the impossible’ and it’s not just democrats. We engineers question everything it’s our job, and the country seems insane right now
As I said in previous reply, the bubble lures you and you are told it is real by the experts, in this case the conservatives too. So who can we trust now? Who is our hero?
No one is perfect. E.g. Schiff is great, but even he makes mistakes.
"Trust but verify" also applies to allies!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.