Of course, some of the Boyle experience was staged, but she can’t be compared with those who have been in musical theatre for years and who have learned stage presence over those years as have Paige and Buckley.
For a novice (and singing in church is not the same as being before the public). She is a phenomenon. Close your eyes and just listen to the 3 singers. Boyle’s voice is different -— but beautiful with fullness and depth. Not easy to do just standing there and not allowing yourself to act out your emotions — as did Paige and Buckley.
You're right. Paige is considered the First Lady of British Musical Theater with 40 years of experience.
She said she considers herself an actress first and a singer second.
Absolutely.
The “close your eyes” part of your post is especially pointed. Boyle has a beautiful voice, but is not beautiful, as are Paige and Buckley. Nor does she have their training.
It may well be staged..but I hope she wins.