Let me see if I understand this:
1. The school has a policy, which he was aware of, stating no premarital sex because it is a Christian College.
2. This young man violated said policy, publicly, by starring in gay porn and it was discovered by the students and administration, who were then notified
3. The promised disciplinary action was instituted
Well, this will have predictable results. The ACLU will jump all over it, the policy will be found unconstitutional, he will win millions, and another private school with Christian values will be discriminated against for having a value as part of their policy.
Sir, you could have gotten a job stocking shelves, or gone to a college that shared YOUR views, but you didn’t. You chose to go to a christian college with a pre marital sex (hetero or homo) ban and then engaged in homosexual sex to pay your tuition to the school? Shame on you. Sounds like this was planned for precisely this kind of gay rights issue fight it will become, and seen as a chance to make a large settlement for the one who broke the rules.
I’ll be surprised if the ACLU takes this up, actually. Grove City is carefully a fully private institution—and the ACLU failed to browbeat the Boy Scouts into accepting perverted scoutmasters in the federal courts (even though they are under continuing persecution at the state and local level) due to their private institution status.
There is even less of a case here (as Grove City College presumably never uses public property for meetings and camp outs, like the Scouts do), and I suspect the ACLU would realize they would be ultimately wasting their money, for a kid who intentionally broke the rules.