Posted on 09/17/2008 12:02:09 PM PDT by goldstategop
TO: SEN. BARACK OBAMA FROM: WILLIAM GALSTON SUBJ: ADJUST OR LOSE DATE: SEPTEMBER 16, 2008
I'll get right to the point: You are in danger of squandering an election most of us thought was unlosable. The reason is simple: on the electorates most important concern the economy -- you have no clear message, and John McCain has filled the void with his own.
This is more than my opinion. The Democracy Corps survey released yesterday proves the case beyond a reasonable doubt. Backed by a wealth of persuasive detail, here is the nub of their conclusion:
In the absence of a coherent change message from Obama, many voters are accepting McCains definition, particularly since they want to change Washington and clean up government. As a result, Obama has lost his double-digit advantage over McCain on the right kind of change.
When I say you have no message, heres what I mean:
First, you are not offering a coherent account of what has gone wrong with the economy why it is no longer working for average families. People are anxious and bewildered; they want to know why jobs are disappearing, why incomes are stagnating, and why prices are soaring. If you dont offer an explanation, McCains will carry the day by default: the problem is the corrupt, self-interested politicians in Washington; the solution is getting them and government in general out of the way.
Second: you are not offering a focused, parsimonious list of remedies for the economic ills you cite. As a result, few if any voters can actually cite a single signature economic proposal you have made. Its not that you dont have ideas. If anything, you have too many. At some point, more becomes less, and you are well beyond that point. You need to decide which three or four economic proposals are most important and repeat them relentlessly for the next seven weeks.
Your campaign already contains everything you need to do this. You could offer a focused economic message with four elements: rebuilding the United States, with an infrastructure bank, generating millions of good jobs that cant be outsourced; creating millions more jobs by leading the world in environmental innovation; significantly reducing the tax burden on average families; and offering health insurance to everyone at a price they can afford. If you say that about your economic plan and nothing else from now until November, theres a good chance your message will get through.
Third: you are not drawing crisp, punchy contrasts between your plans and McCains. An example: the centerpiece of his health care plan is the taxation of employer-provided health care benefits. Pound away at that, and let him explain why throwing workers into the individual health insurance market unprotected is such a wonderful idea. And by the way, while your plan would increase coverage, his would do the opposite. Is that the change Americans want?
Fourth: your stump speech is too long and discursive. It shouldnt last more than fifteen minutes, it should focus on your agenda, not todays news story, it should feature short, declarative sentences, and it should leave no doubt about what you care about the most. Right now, regrettably, few Americans believe that you feel real passion about their economic plight and are willing to wage a tough fight on their behalf. Its your job to convince them otherwise, and you dont have much time to do it.
A message is a thought not only sent, but also received and understood. If your hearers arent getting it, its not a message. The essence of political speech is functional, not aesthetic. It is a tree judged by its fruit, and the fruit is persuasion. Right now youre not persuading the people you need to persuade, and nothing else matters.
Fifth: theres no coordination between an economic message and the rest of your campaign. If you want the focus to be on the economy, thats what your paid advertising and your surrogates should be doing as well. Attacking McCain for employing lobbyists is a waste of precious time and resources; it plays on his turf and accepts his definition of the problem. Moreover, It diverts attention from the core issue a Republican approach to the economy, shared by Bush and McCain, that shafts ordinary Americans and does nothing to help them deal with the challenges of global competition. So far, while the McCain campaign has gone for the jugular, youve gone for the capillaries.
Some Americans wont support you because they think youre too young and inexperienced to be president, or that youre too liberal, or not patriotic enough, or because you might raise taxes, or because youre African-American. Thats inevitable. The good news is that by themselves, these Americans are not a majority. The bad news is that they might become part of a majority if they are joined by the many Americans who are open to supporting you but are turning away because they dont hear you speaking to their concerns in a manner that they can understand.
This is not about you alone; its a matter of political responsibility. Millions of Americans have invested their hopes and dreams in you, and you owe it to them to campaign effectively, which isn't happening right now. Yes, the McCain campaign is replete with exaggerations, evasions, and outright fabrications. Its your responsibility to defeat them, not complain about them. If this means listening to advice you dont want to hear, and getting out of the "comfort zone," so be it.
Three months ago, when you were riding high, the McCain campaign was flat on its back. But give McCain credit: when he was told that to win he had to change, he did. He focused, and he accepted a kind of discipline that he had previously resisted. Now its your turn.
"Show me just what Mohammed brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached." - Manuel II Palelologus
Is this a communist front organization?
The Democrats do have a message on the economy and it is to raise taxes which will plunge it into a deep recession or even a depression. People who have a basic understanding of economics understands this.
"Show me just what Mohammed brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached." - Manuel II Palelologus
As I recall this guy is incredibly creepy looking. He was one of the Clinton droids.
I think this open letter will give Joe Biden a new theme for his stump speech:
“Stand up, Barack! C’mon, Stand up! *rimshot* Get up off your knees Barack, you’re (you can complete the thought here)!” *rimshot*
OK, it might get deleted. I just couldn’t resist.
People are always so quick to compain about "The Campaign". Its easier to blame things on a lackluster campaign, than to simply realize that the swing voters just didnt like your guy/gal.
Now that McCains poll numbers are going to fall a bit, watch for the people who will complain about the campaign.
Obama is in a fix. If he doesn’t set out a clear message on the economy - he will lose. If he does, he still loses because his message will not sit weel.
This is not about you alone
But it is all about Obama to Obama, and he can do nothing to change that.
“...it should feature short, declarative sentences, and it should leave no doubt about what you care about the most.”
Unfortunately, what Obama cares about most is getting elected. And he can’t say that over and over again.
"Show me just what Mohammed brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached." - Manuel II Palelologus
There’s a lot more wrong than just his lack of an economic policy!...
I don't understand why the Dems want to tout such an incredibly impossible goal unless it is clear and simple pandering to the econuts.
He forgot the conclusion:
“And last, since everyone now knows you are nothing but an empty suit and a teleprompter, nothing you do or say in the next 45 days is going to be able to change that”.
Is this Galston guy the one that looks like an ALBINO?
"Show me just what Mohammed brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached." - Manuel II Palelologus
“Theres a lot more wrong than just his lack of an economic policy!...”
You got that right! For starters, how about the fact that there are literally TENS OF MILLIONS OF AMERICAN VOTERS who are going to vote for this total zero! I can’t believe it; I just want to scream! What is the matter with these people!
Shifting the attention to anything BUT success against global terrorism is handing the election to Liberals. Period
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.