Posted on 06/09/2008 4:46:33 PM PDT by SJackson
South Los Angeles resident Erlyne Toney-Alvarez, 67, had always planned to be cremated when she died. Simple. Inexpensive. Graves, she said, are a waste of land occupied by the dead.
Then she saw the intricately plastinated bodies at the Body Worlds exhibit at the California Science Center -- bodies that had been stripped of their fat, filled with plastics and shown off in all their muscular, organic and anatomical glory for the world to see in traveling shows.
Now that, she thought, is the way she wants to go.
"I was so excited," she said of seeing the exhibit with her twin sister, Ernestine Toney-Dixon. "We went to the exhibition hall and we just got so overwhelmed with all this new stuff, and we said, 'We're going to donate our bodies!' "
Toney-Alvarez and her sister were among 115 future body donors who met Saturday with Dr. Gunther von Hagens, the creator of Body Worlds and the inventor of the plastination technique. Forty-seven others in attendance were friends or relatives of the donors.
Many said they were inspired after seeing Body Worlds' anatomical exhibitions. The California Science Center hosted the exhibition's first North American visit, which began in 2004. Since then, Body Worlds has traveled to numerous cities nationwide, including Milwaukee, where it ended its run at the Milwaukee Public Museum on June 1. The exhibit is scheduled to be on display in California until September.
The exhibits feature whole bodies, down to the muscles and organs, that are posed acrobatically. Its first two runs drew record crowds in L.A. There are now four Body Worlds tours rotating among museums in North America. And along the way, hundreds of people have to pledged to donate their bodies for plastination.
According to Dr. Angelina Whalley, Von Hagens' wife, 8,625 people worldwide have agreed to give their bodies to Von Hagens' German-based Institute for Plastination. While 85 percent of donors are from Germany, 728 donors are from the United States.
In his hourlong lecture Saturday, Von Hagens spoke about how, as a young medical student, he was dismayed at the poor quality of anatomical specimens, which were mostly colorless and locked in jars. He developed the plastination technique as an anatomist trying to find a better way to improve specimens, he said.
He also explained the reasons why the bodies are portrayed as acrobatic, life-like models. At Body Worlds' first exhibition in Japan, visitors commented on how dead the specimens looked. Von Hagens said the comments led him to realize that specimens should be portrayed realistically as living humans, similar to the way Renaissance scientists depicted human anatomy in lifelike poses.
Institute officials say 95 percent of donors have signed forms giving permission for their bodies to be publicly displayed. The other bodies are to be used by medical students studying anatomy.
Body Worlds' American donation program started shortly after the exhibit arrived in Los Angeles and visitors began asking museum staff how they could donate their bodies.
Toney-Alvarez said she was intrigued to see how bodies could be used to teach. She was amazed to see how preserved remains could illustrate how cancer consumes the body and how an aneurysm can kill.
The exhibit also touched a personal nerve. In 2003, Toney-Alvarez lost a sister, Irma Toney-Robinson, 60, to an aneurysm, and her father, Edward Toney, 87, to pancreatic cancer.
Donating her body is one way "you can give back to help the public understand," she said.
Her mother, Irma Henry, 85, also agreed to donate her body.
"I thought it was a good idea for medical students at first," Henry said. "Once I looked into it, the first thing that came to mind was how much money I'd save" on funeral expenses.
Many donors talked about how the donation would remove the need to buy a burial plot or pay for cremation. The Institute for Plastination pays for the process, which can take 1,500 work hours and a year to complete. Donors pay only the cost of transporting their bodies to the funeral home.
"I think graves are a waste of real estate," said donor Ron Cooper, 41, a truck mechanic who flew with his wife from Marion, N.C., for Saturday's talk.
"I've only been to see my mother's grave" -- in Michigan -- "twice in the last 20 years," he said.
His wife, Ann Cooper, 38, said she hopes her donation will inspire others to research a genetic disease she has -- polycystic kidney disease -- which causes abnormally large growth of kidneys.
Cooper had one of her kidneys, which weighed 17 pounds, removed; her other kidney is failing.
She said the future donation of her body "is a way for me to give back to education."
David Keil, a 31-year-old engineer from Toronto, said the exhibits encouraged him to quit smoking.
"When I went through and actually saw the lungs, the ones that were black, I said, 'OK. That's it. I had enough,' " he said.
To donate their bodies, donors mail agreement forms to the Institute. Having an attorney witness the signature is recommended if a donor's relatives are not in favor of the donation.
Donors are then given a card explaining that their body must be taken to a designated mortuary nearby that is equipped to prepare the body to be shipped to Germany. Once there, the body's water and fat are replaced by a liquid polymer, such as silicone rubber or polyester, that is later hardened to retain tissue structures.
Von Hagens, who also intends to be plastinated upon his death, said he has been surprised by the "enthusiasm and dedication" of American donors.
"Plastination turns a corpse from an object of mourning to . . . an object of enlightenment," he told the gathering.
Plastinated bodies used by a company that competes with Body Worlds have caused controversy in recent months and prompted a bill by Assemblywoman Fiona Ma (D-San Francisco) that seeks to ensure that people whose remains are on tour consented to their public display.
Body Worlds has publicly supported the legislation. The company underwent a rigorous ethics review by the California Science Center before it was allowed to exhibit in L.A. in 2004 and was able to show that donors had consented to public display of their bodies, said the museum's president, Jeffrey Rudolph.
The competing exhibitor, Atlanta-based Premier Exhibitions Inc., has come under fire because it acknowledged it does not know its donors' identities.
New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo last month reached a settlement with the company, requiring it to provide refunds to attendees who object to the company's use of the bodies.
This was at the Milwaukee Museum recently and I wanted to go, but after careful consideration and reflection of the scriptures I concluded this is nothing more than exploitation and disgraceful to the dead. I could get the same info from a good text book and CD Rom full of MRI and CT images.
Wife and I and out son went to “The Bodies,” in Seattle, which I think is the same format with plasticized Chinese. Parts of this were sickening.
I like the idea of plasticine organs for biology and anatomy departments, but using a whole body is nothing more than a morbid curiosity. There is a lack of diseased organs and such which can be used for study and having them turned into a type of fossil is great, but it should be reserved for research purposes only.
I don’t care what you do with me after I die, but beware, I may raise a stink if you do it wrong.
I can understand for study and medical students, but the rest just seems rather morbid.
Rather silly that the woman thinks a grave is a waste of space, yet will have herself plasticized and take up space.
Obviously I’m not up on this. I take it it’s a traveling exhibition.
I saw this display in Chicago a couple of years ago. It was amazing, very impressive. Not for everyone and it requires a bit of a strong stomach but I think it’s well worth the time to check out.
Yeah, there are like 4 different sets of these and they travel around the world. Our Museum had to be open 24 hours in the last week to accommodate all the visitors. On the plus side the museum was in the red for a long time and I think this got them into the black.
Parts ping...
I think that was the show that came to Rochester. Didn’t they later find out that many of the “exhibits” were from unwilling donors.
The vanity of baby boomers does not cease at death.
Yea I could finally lose weight
There are a bunch of em out there now... coming to your home town soon
Can't you just see this guy checkin' out his future works of art? "Too fat...too thin...juuuuuust right!" or "Hm...I don't have one of those in my collection yet: I hope she dies soon."
You know that he sized them up!
Personally, I don't want to be "worth more to someone dead than alive." It' give others motives.
There are enough Chinese dissidents to stock this exhibit for the next century.
Why is it considered offensive to the media/libs to have pictures of murdered babies on signs but not this?
That was the rumor.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
