Posted on 04/06/2008 8:29:50 AM PDT by moneyrunner
Jonah Goldberg comments on the Russian Duma's defense of the mass starvation of Russian farmers in the Ukraine in 1932-33. They deny claims of genocide by saying that the millions who died were of all ethnic classes.
"There is no historical proof that the famine was organized along ethnic lines. Its victims were million of citizens of the Soviet Union, representing different peoples and nationalities living largely in agricultural areas of the country," the Russian State Duma resolution said.
(Excerpt) Read more at corner.nationalreview.com ...
“The death of one man is a tragedy, the death of millions is a statistic.”
-J. Stalin
OK, so it was just mass murder without a fancy name.
Under the UN’s definition of genocide, this does not qualify. Kulaks were not a people. This was state-organized mass murder. Liberals have killed millions in Africa by banning DDT.
'The first thing we do, let's kill all the lawyers'.
William Shakespeare, Henry VI (Act IV, Scene II).
So Democrats are off the hook for genocide?
Quite a Russian pretzel of logic Mr Goldberg untwists there.
Attacking people for their class is a bad as attacking them for their race; the Left has made a living out of it.
Mass death is the whole and entire purpose of socialism.
Whether the victims are chosen by genotype, social status, or eye-glass wearing; in the end it doesn’t matter.
Finally, it’s just death for the sake of killing, whether by gunshots, starvation, or poisoned koolaid.
This is the unspeakable secret of the 20th century - that the power to liquidate masses of people is the chief and defining power of the contemporary state.
Welcome to the 21st century, in which things will probably get worse.
Class-o-cide?
What if they are poeple without class such as the Hollyweird types and/or RATs?
the MIDDLE CLASS BECOMES THE RICH!!!
that's when their days become numbered.
Its the leftists.. They have zero problem with the murder of most all Muslims..
Looks they are building a case for just that currently..
Once the Worlds leftists have "driven" the Muslims to nuke CITYS..
Then the fat is in the fire..
The worlds leftists will cry out for wholesale murder.. OPENLY..
Instead of privately, like NOW..
Christianity not class is why the Soviets starved the Ukrainians.
Typical liberal semantics distraction... quibble about the titles and names while ignoring the issues. That’s the same thing they do with immigration (”You can’t call them illegal!!”), WMDs (”Saddam’s older chemical weapons don’t count!”), race relations (”Blacks can’t be called racists!”), social program budgets (”A reduced increase is a decrease!”), etc.
Not all mass murders need a special name, nor does a special name make murder more or less palatable.
Amen.
My question is this: why, then, are most American parents just dropping their kids off at government indoctrination centers that teach them to be socialists. Then, to add insult to injury, they go into debt to send these kids to college for more socialistic training. To be indentured servants for the rest of their lives?
I'm running into Americans, now, who just say, "yeah, I'm a socialist, what about it?"
Huh?
I guess when this article talks about "history", it's the rewritten variety. Mass murder is mass murder.
Oh, I just skimmed the Gulag Archipelago -- did you note that it's full of petty bureacrats, getting over on the poor souls they send to "reeducations camps" (i.e., forced labor camps), or to be executed or raped or whatever, because the poor fool wouldn't bend to their personal, petty wishes? Yet, the torturers and cruel bureaucrats all talk in "bureacrat-ese", where, on the record, it sounds all righteous.
E.g., Bureaucrat: "Since you have failed to demonstrate your complete fealty to the government, we will have to provide re-education and rehabilitation from your state of rebellion and treason."
Translation: "You wouldn't move in with me, and so I'm sending to be continually gang-raped as the camp guards' sex slave." It's that ridiculous.
We never learn, do we?
Class warfare. The Dims excel at it.
It shows how much they "care."
Nuthin’ says lovin’ like putting people in the oven.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.