First off, though there are serious problems--as shown by this issue, from what I know, I don't think the majority of LCMS churches are in danger of going liberal, anytime soon anyway.
But, if the Lord is leading you away from LCMS, try some of the new Anglican denominations--which have broken away from the Episcopal Church, and are part of the worldwide Anglican Communion through strongly conservative orthodox Anglican provinces overseas (mostly Africa and South America). Also, for very liturgical Anglo-Catholic form, you have "continuing Anglican" churches.
You can count on any church in the USA with "Anglican" in its name will be "conservative Protestant...liturgical, confessional, and orthodox."
Don't the Anglicans still allow women priests?
I think you are very mistaken about this. From what I read here on FR, it's quite the opposite and they're on the list of those belonging to the NCC.