Replies

I will reply to this one later, but you have my take on David Cook now. Here are the numbers from DialIdol.com:
David Cook 32.65
David Archuleta 22.07
Syesha 15.81

Looks like Syesha will be going home. An all David showdown as we suspected.

Well, there you go. That’s okay. Syesha has a big future ahead of her. It isn’t all that important if she was 2nd or 3rd. Her talent is known and that’s what will see her through the coming years.

Thanks for the info.

BTW, congrats on David C. getting the most votes.

I thought I would broaden my possible understanding of why Syesha picked the songs she did following in more of a theatrical mode, not the expected Pop or Idol mode. Simon was right on about all the performances, by the way; even the song he picked for Cook. But back to Syesha (whom Simon did praise ): The girl is definitely inspired, not chagrined as other contestants have been, over not being #1. Thus, Syesha suddenly seems very well aware of her starring destiny. Why not take this opportunity with intelligent focus to audition in front of millions of viewers which include agents for all the arts, the money powers that be in the BIZ, in what would serve her best interests in upcoming theatrical endeavors.

Syesha has to be well aware Cook or Archuleta are the favorites to win -- a no brainer week after week. Syesha comes on board, as an actress as well. Syesha might just see More than being a Pop/Rock American Idol.

I checked into Playbill and JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR GOSPEL, as an example, in the beginning stages.

I think Syesha is a very intelligent performer and is making the most of her Idol appearances. I would not be surprised to see her in an upcoming play as below. She and other Idol contestants have already been introduced to the likes of those like Andrew Weber.

(Example, even though male performers would lead the cast:)

JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR GOSPEL
Original music: Tim Rice and Andrew Lloyd Weber. Re-conceived and new musical arrangements by Louis St. Louis.
This is a new gospel version of Jesus Christ Superstar. All characters are African American.
*Breakdown pending Equity approval.
1st rehearsal: December 8m 2008. Runs: January 21 – February 22, 2009

Jesus of Nazareth
Judas Iscariot
Mary Magdalene
Pontius Pilate
King Herod
Caiaphas
Annas

Now,Archuleta, to me, is Barry Manilow as a teenager. David is super talented in the technical aspect, tone quality, the judges always applaud for his skill factor which comes from years of training; and would like to see him make good, but he is more Disney material even though 17; which could also present an age problem where one wonders where he would fit in. Too old in another year (18), as he can't be dating his young focus fan group; but not hip, sexy or independent enough for the college crowd mixed genre and up in appreciation.

David Cook will be, I predict if common sense prevails, the Next American Idol. He's more marketable. Which takes nothing away from the talents of Arch or Syesha.

Tina Turner, the Musical, Simply The Best, is also currently aiming for a London debut with a follow up stint on Broadway.

Just my crystal ball prediction past The Days of American Idol.