I kind of liked Tucker, but Scarboro is sort of a punk, although I’m not sure why.
My objection to both of them is that (at least in my admittedly limited exposures) they are both soft-headed sappy go-along guys with few definite ideas and a complete inability to understand or explain great national security issues.
I admit that my impressions of each are severely limited by the fact that I did not find them worth watching and so did not do so for very long.