Posted on 03/08/2008 2:03:28 PM PST by blam
The mystery of mammoth tusks with iron fillings
By By Ned Rozell
March 5, 2008
A giant meteor may have exploded over Alaska thousands of years ago, shooting out metal fragments like buckshot, some of which embedded in the tusks of woolly mammoths and the horns of bison. Simultaneously, a large chunk of the meteor hit Alaska south of Allakaket, sending up a dust cloud that blacked out the sun over the entire state and surrounding areas, killing most of the life in the area.
Embedded iron particles surrounded by carbonized rings in the outer layer of a mammoth tusk from Alaska. Inset photo shows how an object ripped through the tusk. Image courtesy Richard Firestone.
Such is the scenario envisioned by Rick Firestone, a staff scientist at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory in California. Firestone and his colleagues have found mammoth tusks and a bison skull with nickel-rich iron particles in them on one side, suggesting the metal fragments all came from the same direction.
Firestone's theory emerged when his colleague, Alan West of Dewey, Arizona, saw at a Phoenix gem and mineral show a mammoth tusk peppered with tiny bits of metal. Intrigued, West and Firestone looked at tusks owned by the same dealer in Calgary. By passing a magnet over mammoth tusks in Calgary, Firestone and West found seven mammoth tusks collected somewhere near the Yukon River and a bison skull from Siberia that had tiny iron fragments burned into them. The fragments also contained nickel.
"One in 1,000 tusks had this material in it," Firestone said.
Firestone also thinks he may have found the divot left by the ancient meteorite, an impact crater that is now occupied by a round body of water named Sithylemenkat Lake in the upper Kanuti River drainage.
"The creeks coming out of the lake are very rich in nickel," Firestone said, referring to a metal associated with meteorites. "And the shape is consistent with a crater from a meteorite that may have been a half a kilometer in diameter‹a pretty large thing."
A meteorite that big would have torched anything within a 100-mile radius and could have buried the mammoths farther away from the crater, preserving the tusks struck by metal fragments. Firestone said the dust kicked up by the meteor would have eliminated any mammoths that survived the meteor's hit.
"There was probably 10,000 years with no mammoths," he said, adding that other mammoths eventually migrated back into Alaska.
Dale Guthrie, one of Alaska's few experts on mammoths, said he found Firestone's theory interesting, but Alaska scientists who know about impact craters think he is probably off on his guess that Sithylemenkat Lake is the place where a giant meteorite struck about 35,000 years ago (the approximate age of the mammoth tusks). Scientists have confirmed only one impact crater in Alaska‹called Avak, near Barrow‹and have discovered only about 140 impact craters on the entire planet.
Buck Sharpton, an expert on impact craters and the Vice Chancellor for Research at the University of Alaska Fairbanks, said the lake would have to be much older than 35,000 years because it has no rim associated with more recent impact craters and doesn't look to him like an impact crater. He thinks the iron bits in the tusks could be cavities filled by "being immersed for millennia in porous sedimentary fill through which iron-rich water percolated."
As for Sithylemenkat Lake, Gordon Herreid didn't mention a possible meteorite impact when he wrote a 1969 geology report on the lake for the state (which ordered the investigation because of possible nickel deposits there). Jan Cannon wrote in the journal Science in 1977 that the lake looked to be the only visible impact crater in Alaska based on a study of Landsat satellite images. One year later, William Patton of the U.S. Geological Survey argued in Science that glaciers, rather than a meteorite, created the lake.
© AlaskaReport News
Heck, I was expecting to read an article about prehistoric dentistry.
It was the evil Clovis Shotgun. It wiped out all Pleistocene megafauna in North America eventually. Such weapons in the hands of unprincipled peons without Al Gore, Ted Kennedy and Charles Schumer to regulate their behavior always leads to disaster.
lol
Even as we speak, Elmer Keith is telling God he should have used a bigger meteor.
very interesting!
I recently finished reading that book. Very interesting!
Mammoth dentistry.
Although informed on many things, Rush has said nothing about ‘young skulls full of tusk.’
In mammoth dental schools, instructors drilled the lessons into students’ heads, then tried to extract it with tests.
The failure of one mammoth oral surgery at the North Pole led to the creation of the Arctic Cap. Al Gore was so steamed he could hardly polar bear it.
And the Dental Assistants were Lab Radors.
2008-03-09 nails, yellow
I would like to commend the government scientists for deciding that this lake is an impact crater. Is there any way that it can be blamed on Bush? Cheney? Halliburton? Global Warming?
I'm a big Fleetwood Mac fan and I've never heard that one before.
That post deserves a prize.
Beware making sober replies to serial punsters.
“And the Dental Assistants were Lab Radors.”
And I bet they all had attractive canines.
(Sad, how a mammoth thread like this is going to the dogs).
Thanks for the ping!
I hope there’s a sequel, regarding the earlier waves of material, but it could easily fall to other researchers to flesh it out.
(Sad, how a mammoth thread like this is going to the dogs).
It can be heavy sledding for Mammoth's Best Friend, especially if they are thirsty and their tongues stick to the woof of their mouths.
Having read most of the book, I would like to point out that tusks were found in other areas that were also peppered with iron bits. In addition, when the authors went to various Clovis sites to try to determine if the Clovis people were killed off by a comet crash, they ran a strong magnet up and down the sides of the excavation cuts. Large numbers of iron particles were attracted right at the Clovis level, and much less before and after. This test was done at a number of Clovis sites, and also at the Carolina Bays, always with the same results. The book is quite interesting for those with a scientific turn of mind, as they go into great detail as to how and where they conducted their rather convincing research.
“woof of their mouths.”
Now you’re barking up the wrong tree. To imply dogs have woofers is way off bass.
Well put.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.