Posted on 02/19/2008 11:26:02 AM PST by Nachum
More high school girls are playing competitive sports than ever before. But for some devoutly religious girls, balancing faith and athletics can be a challenge. This week in Washington, DC, a Muslim high school track star was kicked out of a meet because her special uniform violated competition rules.
Last month in Canada, the issue made national headlines when a 14-year old soccer player was ejected from a game for wearing her hijaab head scarf. Here in Connecticut, a unique girls basketball team has so far managed to skirt the controversy.
The girls can remain true to traditional Judaic principles and still do just about anythingThe girls practice lay-up shots before the evening game. They call themselves the BCA Skirts. BCA – for Beth Chana Academy, a private Orthodox Jewish school in Orange, Connecticut. And Skirts for the traditional long dress the girls wear off the court...and on. "It's my religion and I wouldn't give it up for anything. So had I had a choice between religion or basketball, I would definitely pick religion. So now that I have a chance to combine the two and have religion and basketball, it's just a very good opportunity," says 16-year old Ariella Hecht.
When in public, Orthodox Jewish law requires young women to dress modestly - with skirts that fall below the knee. They also cover up from their neck to their elbows.
"It's to show the world out there that I have more to me than what meets the eye. And I'm gonna cover my body because if you want to get to know me, you're going to have to get to know my insides," she says.
Four years ago, the school decided to organize a girls' basketball team, and name it after their unorthodox uniforms. The BCA Skirts aren't part of an established league but they compete informally against many New Haven area schools. Principal Jeanne Rice believes the girls can remain true to traditional Judaic principles and still do just about anything.
"Initially, it was kind of...lets get together, lets have some fun you know and meet some other schools and play together. But along the way the girls have developed this amazing tenacity. They're just spectacular athletes and people don't expect that, you know, from these girls," she says.
Some girls wear ankle-length skirts with their Nike's. 17-year-old point guard Batsheva Levine prefers to wear leggings with a skirt that falls just below her knee. She says the team's unusual outfits can be an advantage.
"Sometimes when schools come in, they'll like give us looks you know, and they'll be like, 'Aw, like you know, we have this game in bag" and like "short little Jews in skirts? We're gonna do this real well,'" she says. "We've surprised ourselves, actually, that we've had an undefeated season so far."
Tonight's game is against their toughest rival - an urban charter school in New Haven…Amistad Academy.
Its' their second match-up, so players Shahara Murphy and Jasmine Ramirez say they weren't as surprised this time by the Skirts' uniform. Amistad won the game.
"My only problem is like them tripping over and then the ball…they lose the ball and it goes out. But I think they're really fast on the court to have skirts on," says Ramirez.
When you're rooted in tradition, you can aim highThe National Federation of State High School Associations allows students to modify athletic uniforms for religious or medical reasons, as long as it doesn't create dangerous playing conditions. Officials say there's no hard data, but anecdotally they're hearing that more students are asking for uniform modifications nationwide. BCA coach Jamie Bartone says she never expected to be working with players in skirts.
"The way they look at the game, it surprises me how like, it doesn't even come into consideration. They have skirts on and that's what they're used to and that's how they play. A few of them actually want to try and pursue basketball at the college level," she says.
And the girls say they're not afraid of what will happen when their colleges find out they can't dribble the ball between their legs. The BCA Skirts say basketball's taught them that when you're rooted in tradition, you can aim high.
It could be a mild advantage, in that one could hide (for that critical 1/10 second) leg motion.
Disadvatage would be stride and some dribble moves.
I would think some sort of really baggy pant/”scort” (skirt/short) combo could be worked out to lengthen the stride. I mean the whole goal is: modesty & not dressing in men’s clothes. Some sort of uniquely female modest clothing could be developed.
I think this is a good idea. However, as in post # 2, I can see the possibility of some disadvantages due to clothing. But if they want to play at a mild disadvantage for modesty’s sake, I say let them do it.
so let them wear shorts that come just below the knee......rme
I’m thinking what’s wrong with capri pants?
There's an entrepreneurial opportunity here: Fatwas-R-Us.com, where you can get a sympathetic imam to issue a favorable fatwa for five bucks.
I see some sort of “baggy long short” as a perfectly acceptable answer as would probably most people, but there is a general negative mitzvah against women wearing men’s clothing — pants being men’s clothing in the eyes of many elders.
Due to the lack of an authoritative organized governing body for Jewish people to make this sort of ruling, the general result is to follow the most conservative voices— which is skirts only.
Me, I would ride the edge of the rule, and do a baggy (but relatively fitting) pants with some sort of shorter-than-normal skirt -— I think both goals could be achieved.
Jewish people don’t have fatwas.
ping
Hmmm.... I need to check my reading glasses.
Great photos here; I did not know, this is part of the Southern Connecticut Hebrew Academy; my niece goes there. (She’s young, not at the H.S.)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.